QlikView vs Minitab: A Comparative Analysis
Introduction
Choosing the right business intelligence tool is crucial for effective data analysis and reporting. Qlikview and Minitab are two established players in this field, each with its unique strengths and application contexts.
Qlikview excels in data visualization and interactive dashboards, whereas Minitab is renowned for its statistical analysis capabilities, particularly in Six Sigma projects.
However, for those seeking a more intuitive and agile experience, we'll explore how Sourcetable offers a modernized, spreadsheet-like interface that syncs with your data, serving as a contemporary alternative for business intelligence tasks.
What is QlikView?
QlikView is a guided analytics solution designed for rapidly developing and delivering analytics applications and dashboards. It utilizes an associative engine to provide dynamic data views and an interactive user experience.
-
QlikView is a guided analytics solution designed for rapidly developing and delivering analytics applications and dashboards. It utilizes an associative engine to provide dynamic data views and an interactive user experience.
The software is capable of compressing data and storing it in memory, which enables multiple users to concurrently explore this data. QlikView's direct connection to data sources enhances its capability to deliver real-time insights without limiting users to predefined drill paths or dashboards, ensuring a fully associative experience across all data utilized for analysis.
What is Minitab?
Minitab is a company specializing in data analytics solutions. It offers statistical software geared towards predictive analytics, aiding businesses in making data-driven decisions.
-
Minitab is a company specializing in data analytics solutions. It offers statistical software geared towards predictive analytics, aiding businesses in making data-driven decisions.
-
Key Offerings
- Statistical software for predictive analytics
- Tools for continuous improvement and innovation
- Systems for managing and sharing improvement initiatives
Designed for businesses, Minitab's suite of tools addresses various business challenges. The availability of these tools on the cloud enhances accessibility and collaboration.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Key Features of QlikView
Associative Engine |
The associative engine is central to QlikView, enabling users to uncover data insights and relationships across various sources. |
Intuitive Visual Discovery |
Intuitive visual discovery allows for easy interpretation of data through visual representations, enhancing the analytical experience. |
Qlik Cloud Analytics |
Qlik Cloud Analytics is a cloud-based SaaS solution, facilitating active analytics and augmenting human intuition with AI-powered insights. |
Qlik Sense |
Qlik Sense, an on-premises solution, works alongside QlikView to transition users from passive to active data analytics, leveraging AI to enhance decision-making. |
Key Features of Minitab
Statistical Analysis Features |
Basic statistics including descriptive statistics.Hypothesis tests: one-sample Z-tests, one- and two-sample t-tests, paired t-tests.Regression analysis: linear, nonlinear, binary, ordinal, and nominal regression.Stability studies with residual, factorial, contour, and surface plots.Multivariate control charts: T2, generalized variance, MEWMA.Process capability analysis: Sixpack, tolerance intervals.Quality tools: cause-and-effect diagrams, control charts.Design of experiments: screening, plackett-burman, factorial designs.Reliability/survival analysis: distribution analysis, accelerated life testing.Power and sample size analysis for various statistical tests.Predictive analytics: machine learning, classification, regression.Time series and forecasting: trend analysis, decomposition, ARIMA.Nonparametric tests: sign test, wilcoxon test, kruskal-wallis test.Equivalence tests for one- and two-sample, paired tests.Statistical tables for chi-square, fisher's exact, and other tests. |
Graphical Analysis Features |
Graph Builder for scatterplots, boxplots, bubble plots, bar charts, and more.Dynamic graphs update automatically with data changes.Brushing graphs to explore data points of interest.Export options for graphs: TIF, JPEG, PNG, BMP, GIF, EMF. |
Advantages of Using Qlikview for Business Intelligence
Efficient Data Analysis
Qlikview's dynamic dashboards enhance quick data interpretation, leveraging in-memory technology for speed and effective data visualization for insightful analytics.
Collaboration and Decision Making
The tool fosters team collaboration, enabling data-driven decision-making through shared, interactive reports.
Implementation and Usability
With its simplicity, Qlikview is easy to implement, allowing businesses to quickly benefit from its self-service BI capabilities without extensive training.
Data Security and Performance
Qlikview ensures data security and maintains high performance with its powerful QIX Engine, even with large datasets, thanks to good data compression.
Cost-Effectiveness
As a cost-effective solution, Qlikview provides a robust set of features for businesses looking to leverage business intelligence without significant investment.
Disadvantages of Using Qlikview for Business Intelligence
Inefficiency in Real-Time Data Analysis
Qlikview may not be the most efficient tool for real-time data analysis, which can impede timely decision-making.
RAM Limitations
Despite having less RAM limitations, Qlikview may still encounter performance issues with large data sets.
Technical Skill Requirement
Technical expertise is required to develop applications in Qlikview, potentially limiting its accessibility to non-technical users.
Integration Challenges
Embedding Qlikview with other software may be cumbersome, leading to potential integration issues.
Customer Support Concerns
Poor customer support can affect troubleshooting and user experience negatively.
Outdated Tools and Interfaces
The presence of old tools and interfaces may reduce productivity and user satisfaction.
Cost Prohibitive
Qlikview's pricing may be prohibitive for small to medium-sized businesses, making it a less viable option.
User Satisfaction
Poor ratings in surveys indicate potential dissatisfaction among users, which may reflect in its overall market reputation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Qlikview
How much memory does QlikView use when running a script compared to working in the layout?
QlikView uses 3-4 times as much memory when running a script as when working in the layout.
Can QlikView join fields with different names?
Yes, QlikView can join fields with different names using an alias or AS statement.
How does QlikView handle large amounts of data?
QlikView can handle a few million rows of typical transaction data on a PC with 512MB of RAM, and up to one billion rows of transaction data on large servers.
Can QlikView automatically join fields?
Yes, QlikView can automatically join fields with the same name.
How can QlikView be shared with others?
QlikView can be shared with others using QlikView Server or QlikView Publisher.
Use Cases for Qlikview
-
Improving efficiency, customer service, and sales at a fast-food chain
-
Simplifying analytics through a company-wide portal for a financial software company
-
Boosting operational success for a retail company
-
Lowering costs and reducing effort in the loan conversion process for a financial institution
Advantages of Minitab for Business Intelligence
User-Friendly Interface
Minitab's intuitive interface facilitates ease of use for reporting and data analytics, enhancing efficiency in business intelligence tasks.
Statistical Analysis Capabilities
With robust statistical tools, Minitab enables comprehensive analysis, crucial for informed decision-making in business intelligence.
Data Visualization Tools
Effective data visualization features in Minitab aid in the clear communication of analytical results, a key aspect of business reporting.
Software Compatibility
Minitab's compatibility with other software packages ensures seamless integration and continuity in business intelligence workflows.
Time-Saving Features
The time-saving functionalities of Minitab expedite business intelligence processes, from data analysis to reporting.
Support and Resources
Extensive support and resources available for Minitab users bolster reliability and effectiveness in business intelligence tasks.
Disadvantages of Minitab for Business Intelligence
Limited Programming and Data Manipulation
Minitab's limited programming capabilities restrict its use in complex data analytics. Businesses requiring sophisticated programming for customized analysis may find Minitab inadequate.
User-Friendliness for Beginners
Beginners may encounter a steep learning curve with Minitab, potentially delaying proficiency and impacting productivity in business intelligence tasks.
Cost Considerations
As a relatively expensive option, Minitab may not be the most cost-effective choice for businesses looking to maximize their investment in data analytics tools.
Non-Statistical Analysis Limitations
Minitab's limited non-statistical analysis capabilities can be a hindrance when businesses need to perform a broader range of analyses outside of statistical methods.
Platform Availability
Being available only on Windows, Minitab restricts businesses that use other operating systems from integrating it into their data analytics processes.
Frequently Asked Questions About Minitab
Does Minitab offer any special pricing for educational purposes?
Yes, Minitab offers special academic pricing, including special pricing for students, teachers, and instructors.
Are there any discounts available for government agencies interested in Minitab?
Yes, Minitab offers special pricing options for government agencies.
Can I obtain a multi-user license for Minitab?
Yes, Minitab offers Multi-User Licenses.
Who should I contact if I need help with the order and payment process for Minitab?
Cleverbridge Customer Service can assist you with the order and payment process for Minitab.
Who can I reach out to for technical support with Minitab?
You can contact Minitab Support for technical assistance.
Use Cases for Minitab
-
Increasing annual cost savings by managing and tracking project metrics
-
Reducing product overfill to save costs
-
Standardizing employee review processes for performance evaluation
-
Validating manufacturing processes to ensure quality
-
Analyzing and improving sales operations through data insights
Why Sourcetable is the Superior Choice for Business Intelligence
-
Streamlined Data Integration
Sourcetable offers a seamless approach to data management by automatically syncing data across various services directly into a user-friendly spreadsheet interface. This eliminates the complexity associated with traditional BI tools like Qlikview that require extensive setup and maintenance for data integration.
-
Intuitive Interface
Unlike Qlikview, which utilizes an associative engine for visual data discovery, Sourcetable provides a straightforward spreadsheet-like interface that is familiar to most users, reducing the learning curve and increasing adoption rates across organizations.
-
Enhanced Collaboration
Sourcetable's platform is designed for real-time collaboration, enabling teams to work together efficiently without the need for complex setups. This surpasses the collaboration capabilities of Qlikview, where real-time action is limited to specific deployments.
-
Optimized Reporting
The simplicity of Sourcetable's reporting tools allows for quick generation of reports, making it more accessible than Qlikview and Minitab for users who need to produce insights rapidly and share them across their organization.
-
Cost-Effectiveness
By consolidating multiple tools into one straightforward interface, Sourcetable can reduce costs associated with managing separate business intelligence solutions, providing a cost-effective alternative to both Qlikview and Minitab.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Comparison Between QlikView and Minitab
QlikView and Minitab are both analytics solutions used for business intelligence. They provide tools for organizations to analyze and visualize data, aiding strategic decision-making.
QlikView and Minitab are both analytics solutions used for business intelligence. They provide tools for organizations to analyze and visualize data, aiding strategic decision-making.
Analytics Capabilities
Both solutions offer advanced analytics capabilities. QlikView with its associative engine enables intuitive visual discovery, while Minitab offers statistical analysis and process improvement tools.
Business Intelligence
QlikView and Minitab put business intelligence in the hands of more people, democratizing data analysis within organizations.
Deployment Options
They can be deployed in different environments to suit organizational needs. QlikView is available both in the cloud, with Qlik Cloud Analytics, and on-premises, with Qlik Sense. Minitab also offers flexibility with its desktop applications and cloud services.
Collaboration and Action
Both platforms facilitate collaboration among team members. QlikView does this in real-time, allowing for immediate action and decision-making.
AI and Insights
QlikView and Minitab utilize AI to enhance data analysis. QlikView's AI-powered insights complement human intuition, while Minitab uses machine learning algorithms to uncover trends and patterns.
QlikView vs Minitab
Deployment and Accessibility
QlikView offers flexibility in deployment with options for cloud-based SaaS through Qlik Cloud Analytics and on-premises solutions such as Qlik Sense. In contrast, Minitab is traditionally known for its desktop applications, with a stronger emphasis on on-premises deployment.
Analytics and Data Visualization
QlikView leverages an associative engine for intuitive visual discovery and real-time collaboration, catering to a broader range of business intelligence needs. Minitab focuses primarily on statistical analysis and quality improvement, providing in-depth statistical tools that may not feature the same level of visual discovery as QlikView.
Target Audience
QlikView is designed to put business intelligence in the hands of more people, making data analytics accessible to a wider audience. Minitab is generally targeted towards professionals and organizations with a strong focus on statistics and quality improvement methodologies.
AI Integration and Insights
QlikView integrates AI-powered insights to augment human intuition, while Minitab's strength lies in its statistical analysis capabilities without an explicit emphasis on artificial intelligence.
Real-time Collaboration
QlikView promotes real-time collaboration and action, allowing users to make strategic decisions quickly. Minitab does not emphasize real-time collaboration in the same way, focusing more on individual statistical analysis.
Comparison of QlikView, Minitab, and SourceTable
QlikView
QlikView is an analytics solution known for its associative engine that revolutionized how organizations use data. It enables intuitive visual discovery, allowing more people to engage with business intelligence. QlikView is versatile, offering cloud-based SaaS deployment with Qlik Cloud Analytics and on-premises solutions with Qlik Sense. It incorporates AI-powered insights and supports real-time collaboration and action.
Minitab
Minitab is primarily a statistics software that specializes in enabling users to perform complex statistical analyses. It’s often used for Six Sigma and other quality improvement projects. Unlike QlikView, Minitab focuses more on in-depth statistical analysis and less on broad business intelligence and data visualization.
SourceTable
SourceTable is a spreadsheet interface that connects to various data sources, allowing users to create automated reports and dashboards. It is designed to be user-friendly, offering data manipulation and visualization without the need for advanced programming skills. SourceTable focuses on ease of use and accessibility for users who might not have specialized training in data analytics.
Contrast
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Frequently Asked Questions About Sourcetable
What is Sourcetable and who typically uses it?
Sourcetable is a spreadsheet application that replaces workflows typically done in Excel, Google Sheets, and Business Intelligence tools. It is commonly used by growth teams and business operations teams.
How does Sourcetable integrate with third-party applications?
Sourcetable syncs data from over 100 applications and most databases, with data integrations updating every 15 minutes on the regular plan and every 5 minutes on the pro plan.
Do I need to know how to code to use Sourcetable?
No, Sourcetable does not require coding to use. Users can query data and build live models without coding.
How much does Sourcetable cost?
Sourcetable is $50 per month on the starter plan and $250 per month on the pro plan. Additional seats cost $20 per month per user after the first five included in the pro plan.
Does Sourcetable offer a trial period?
Yes, all plans of Sourcetable come with a 14-day free trial period.
Qlikview Pricing Plans
-
Standard Plan Features
The Standard Plan of Qlikview is designed for a minimum of 20 full users. It includes a suite of features for data analytics, such as:
- 25 GB/year of data analysis capacity
- Capability to connect and combine hundreds of data sources
- Interactive data visualizations and dashboards
- Augmented analytics with artificial intelligence
- Options for team collaboration and sharing
- 24x7 customer support for users
-
Premium and Enterprise Plan Enhancements
Both Premium and Enterprise Plans encompass all Standard Plan offerings with additional advanced features:
- Increased data analysis capacity (50 GB/year for Premium, 500 GB/year for Enterprise)
- Automated report compilation and delivery
- Additional data source connections
- Predictive analytics with automated machine learning
- No-code automation builder triggers
- Enterprise-grade data governance
- Customized customer success plan
-
User Capacity Notifications
Qlikview provides alerts for users approaching their data capacity limit, ensuring proactive management of resources.
Minitab Subscription Cost
Minitab provides a variety of subscription options, with annual plans available. The starting price for a subscription is $1851.00 USD, but final costs may include sales tax depending on the purchaser's location. During the checkout process, customers can view prices in their local currency. Subscriptions encompass all software updates, technical support, and complimentary upgrades to the latest version of the software.
-
Minitab provides a variety of subscription options, with annual plans available. The starting price for a subscription is $1851.00 USD, but final costs may include sales tax depending on the purchaser's location. During the checkout process, customers can view prices in their local currency. Subscriptions encompass all software updates, technical support, and complimentary upgrades to the latest version of the software.
-
Additional Modules and Pricing
The predictive analytics module in Minitab features machine learning algorithms. Industry-specific modules offer tailored prompts and statistical guidance for sectors such as healthcare, supply chain, and insurance. Modules cater to various professions and industries, enhancing the software's relevance and application.
-
Discount Options
- Minitab provides special pricing for academic institutions.
- GSA pricing is available for eligible government organizations.
- Volume discounts are offered, benefiting organizations requiring multiple subscriptions.
User Reviews and Ratings of QlikView
-
Overall Impressions
QlikView has garnered an overall rating of 4.3 out of 5, reflecting generally positive feedback from users. Its functionality is particularly praised with a 4.5 rating, while ease-of-use, customer support, and value for money each stand at a solid 4 out of 5.
-
Functionality and Use Cases
Users appreciate QlikView as a powerful business intelligence (BI) tool, with its versatility in data visualization and its capability to integrate multiple data sources being highlighted. Its strength in creating complex reports and use for sales and inventory dashboards is noted. However, it is mentioned that it may not be the best in class for data visualization options and is less user-friendly with certain data sources like BW and Big Data.
-
Usability
The ease-of-use of QlikView receives mixed reviews. While it is deemed easy to use and implement, with an intuitive interface, some users find the UI clunky and the software less accommodating for detailed reporting. Integration with R is not supported, adding to the limitations for some advanced users.
-
Performance
QlikView's performance is fast due to in-memory processing, and it is capable of handling scheduled batch jobs for ETL. However, with heavy data volume, users have experienced slow response times and slight delays in real-time data sync. It is also noted that QlikView cannot export a list of all currently licensed users or write back to the database.
-
Value and Support
Many users feel that QlikView provides a ton of value, particularly for students writing their thesis and for the automation of report distribution and creation. It allows customization using VBA or other programming languages. Despite being more expensive than some alternatives, users consider it a valuable investment. A wide user group and a support forum contribute to the community and support available for QlikView users.
-
Comparisons and Limitations
- QlikView is not as advanced in visualization capabilities compared to some competitors.
- It is considered less capable than Qlik Sense, Tableau, and PowerBI.
User Reviews of Minitab
Minitab has garnered 308 reviews with an average rating of 4.4. The software is praised for its functionality, receiving a 4.5 out of 5 rating in this area. Ease-of-use, customer support, and value for money all received a 4 out of 5 rating from users. The application is recognized for its capability to produce data analysis outputs in an understandable manner, allowing users to analyze data graphically, and for its utility across various applications.
-
Minitab has garnered 308 reviews with an average rating of 4.4. The software is praised for its functionality, receiving a 4.5 out of 5 rating in this area. Ease-of-use, customer support, and value for money all received a 4 out of 5 rating from users. The application is recognized for its capability to produce data analysis outputs in an understandable manner, allowing users to analyze data graphically, and for its utility across various applications.
-
Usability
Considered a highly rated statistical software, Minitab is lauded for its ease of use, with a small learning curve and a user-friendly interface. It is characterized as easier to use than other statistical packages and is deemed a good tool for beginners. However, some users note that Minitab's dashboard and worksheet could use improvement.
-
Support and Deployment
Users highlight Minitab's good customer service, with some reviews mentioning excellent support. The software can be deployed to multiple computers using a license server, enhancing its accessibility for teams.
-
Functionality
Minitab offers a comprehensive set of statistical features, including ANOVA, hypothesis tests, and regression analysis. It's reported to be the best tool for quality management and a must-have for Lean Black Belts. While it's considered to have great graphical outputs, some users believe that Excel has better graphical capabilities, although Minitab has been improving in this aspect.
-
Application and Value
The software is used by a diverse range of professionals, from Black Belts to Statisticians, and is not limited to classroom use. It's highlighted as a professional statistical software, affordable for academics, and requiring less disk space than its competitors. However, opinions are mixed regarding its completeness and price, with some considering it less complete and more expensive than other packages.
-
Comparison to Other Packages
While Minitab is easier to use and allows for easier data analysis compared to other statistical packages, it is mentioned that its statistical tools are relatively basic. Despite this, its graphical analysis is considered the best among its offerings.
Conclusion
In sum, Qlikview and Minitab serve distinct roles within the realm of business intelligence. Qlikview excels in data visualization and interactive dashboards, while Minitab is preferred for its advanced statistical analysis capabilities.
However, for businesses seeking a more streamlined business intelligence solution, Sourcetable offers a compelling alternative. It integrates data in real-time from various services into a user-friendly spreadsheet interface.
This approach simplifies the complexity typically associated with business intelligence tools, potentially saving time and resources for users who prioritize ease of use and familiarity.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Simplify Your BI Tooling
Sourcetable is the AI spreadsheet that lets you analyze your data in one place. Get unlimited access free for 14 days.