Qlikview
Kibana

QlikView vs Kibana: A Comparative Analysis

Jump to

    Introduction

    Choosing the right business intelligence tool is crucial for effective data analysis and reporting. Qlikview and Kibana are two prominent platforms in this field, each with its distinct features and use cases.

    Qlikview is known for its powerful in-memory data processing and associative data modeling, while Kibana excels in visualizing and navigating Elasticsearch data. This comparison will delve into their strengths and limitations.

    Additionally, we'll explore how Sourcetable offers a modern alternative with a spreadsheet-like interface that seamlessly syncs with your data, providing a more intuitive solution for business intelligence tasks.

    Qlikview

    What is QlikView?

    QlikView is a guided analytics solution designed to empower users to rapidly create and deploy guided analytics applications and dashboards. Its core feature is the associative engine, which dynamically generates new views of data as users explore and interact.

    Kibana

    What is Kibana?

    Kibana is a data analytics platform that specializes in the visualization, monitoring, and management of data. It is widely recognized for its capabilities in log and application monitoring, as well as search analytics. Kibana provides a comprehensive suite of tools for observability and security, making it a versatile choice for data analysis and operational intelligence.

    • Data Visualization

      Kibana enables users to create interactive charts, maps, and graphs for real-time data visualization. Its intuitive interface allows for the easy exploration and understanding of large datasets.

    • Monitoring Tools

      As a monitoring tool, Kibana offers log analytics and application performance insights. It facilitates the detection of issues and aids in the troubleshooting process.

    • Search Analytics

      Kibana enhances search capabilities by providing detailed analytics, thereby improving data retrieval and analysis.

    • Observability and Security

      Kibana is leveraged for observability, granting visibility into IT environments. It also plays a crucial role in security, helping to identify and respond to threats.

    Qlikview

    Key Features of QlikView

    Associative Engine

    The associative engine is the core feature that distinguishes QlikView, enabling users to explore data connections in an intuitive manner.

    Intuitive Visual Discovery

    Intuitive visual discovery allows for easy interpretation and manipulation of data through dynamic visuals.

    Qlik Cloud Analytics

    As a cloud-based SaaS deployment, Qlik Cloud Analytics facilitates active analytics with AI-powered insights and a move towards more proactive data engagement.

    Qlik Sense

    Qlik Sense, an on-premises solution, complements QlikView by extending its capabilities to support active analytics with a focus on enhancing human intuition through AI.

    Kibana

    Kibana Features Overview

    Data Visualization and Management

    Kibana empowers users to visualize Elasticsearch data and navigate the Elastic Stack efficiently. It includes tools like Lens, Time Series Visual Builder, and Vega visualizations for creating comprehensive visual representations of data. Users can share these visualizations with team members and export them as PDF or PNG files. Furthermore, Kibana visualizations can be embedded directly into webpages.

    Access Control and Security

    For secure data management, Kibana supports role-based access control (RBAC) and anonymous access for public sharing. It provides field- and document-level security, encrypted communications, and features a runtime fields editor for custom fields creation. Kibana also integrates with SAML single sign-on (SSO) and allows login with external identity providers.

    Organization and Customization

    Organizing dashboards is streamlined with Kibana's support for spaces. Customization options are extensive due to the availability of Kibana plugins. Users can manage roles using the role management API, and handle saved objects through both UI and API. The interface can be personalized with a dark theme, applicable at the individual space level.

    Deployment and Scalability

    Kibana's deployment is versatile, capable of running on various infrastructures including physical hardware, virtual environments, and public clouds with Elastic Cloud Enterprise (ECE). Deployment can be simplified with Elastic Cloud on Kubernetes, and official Helm Charts and Docker containers are provided for easy setup.

    Geospatial Analysis

    With the Maps app, Kibana parses geographical data, plotting multiple layers, and adding unique indices. It features vector tiles for performance, region maps, and the ability to color boundary vector shapes. The Elastic Maps Service and Server enhance map functionality, and Kibana can trigger notifications with geo alerting for entity movements relative to specified boundaries.

    Qlikview

    Advantages of Using Qlikview for Business Intelligence

    Self-Service BI Tool

    Qlikview enables users to manage BI tasks independently, enhancing efficiency in reporting and data analytics.

    Enhanced Data Interpretation

    The dynamic dashboards of Qlikview facilitate quick data interpretation, streamlining the decision-making process.

    Collaborative Decision-Making

    Its collaborative features support team-based analysis, fostering data-driven decisions across departments.

    Implementation and Usability

    Qlikview's simplicity in implementation and ease of use reduce the learning curve for users.

    Data Security and Speed

    Robust data security protocols and high-speed processing capabilities ensure safe and swift data handling.

    Innovative In-Memory Technology

    Qlikview's in-memory technology supports quick data retrieval and manipulation, improving analytics workflows.

    Data Compression and Visualization

    Efficient data compression techniques coupled with superior data visualization options enhance the BI experience.

    Cost Efficiency

    Qlikview provides a cost-effective solution for businesses seeking powerful BI tools without exorbitant expenses.

    Qlikview

    Disadvantages of Using Qlikview for Business Intelligence

    Inefficiency in Real-Time Data Analysis

    Qlikview may not be the best option for real-time data analysis due to potential inefficiencies.

    Technical Expertise Requirement

    The necessity for technical expertise in application development is a significant barrier for Qlikview users.

    Integration Challenges

    Embedding Qlikview with other software solutions can be cumbersome, posing integration challenges.

    Limited Customer Support

    Users may encounter substandard customer support when seeking assistance with Qlikview.

    Outdated Tools and Interfaces

    The presence of old tools and interfaces in Qlikview can detract from user experience.

    Cost Concerns for Smaller Businesses

    The cost of Qlikview may be prohibitive for small or medium-sized enterprises.

    User Satisfaction and Ratings

    Qlikview's poor ratings in user satisfaction surveys may reflect its perceived shortcomings.

    Qlikview

    Frequently Asked Questions About Qlikview

    How does QlikView handle memory usage?

    QlikView uses 3-4 times as much memory when running a script as when working in the layout.

    What volume of data can QlikView handle?

    QlikView can handle a few million rows of typical transaction data on a PC with 512MB of RAM, and up to one billion rows on large servers.

    Can QlikView automatically join fields?

    Yes, QlikView can automatically join fields with the same name, and it can join fields with different names using an alias or AS statement.

    How can QlikView read tables from various sources?

    QlikView can use SQL-like syntax on text files, use the table file wizard to load fix-record text files, and read tables from web pages using the table file wizard.

    How can QlikView documents be shared and security enforced?

    QlikView can be shared with others using QlikView Server or QlikView Publisher, and it can limit who can use a document using section access.

    Use Cases for Qlikview

    • Qlikview

      Improving efficiency, customer service, and sales as demonstrated by Dominos Pizza

    • Qlikview

      Simplifying analytics through a company-wide portal as implemented by Intuit

    • Qlikview

      Enhancing operational success in the retail sector as shown by Urban Outfitters

    • Qlikview

      Reducing costs and effort in converting loan prospects as in the case of Integra Financial

    Kibana

    Advantages of Using Kibana for Business Intelligence

    Data Visualization and Analytics

    Kibana facilitates the visualization and analysis of Elasticsearch data, transforming raw data into insightful charts and graphs. This feature is crucial for businesses to glean actionable insights from their data.

    System Monitoring and Debugging

    For monitoring production environments and debugging, Kibana provides a clear interface, making it efficient for identifying and resolving issues within business systems.

    Log Parsing and Aggregation

    With Kibana's automatic parsing and aggregation of logs, businesses can streamline their data processing, thus enhancing their analytical capabilities.

    Intuitive User Experience

    Kibana's intuitive design ensures that users can easily navigate the tool, making it accessible for users of all skill levels for various business intelligence tasks.

    Advanced Filtering and Real-Time Search

    Advanced filtering and real-time search capabilities enable users to drill down into specifics, providing businesses with immediate insights into their data.

    Complement to Other Tools

    As a complement to other logging solutions, Kibana enhances a business's intelligence infrastructure without necessitating the replacement of existing systems.

    Documentation and Support

    Strong documentation supports Kibana users by providing clear guidance, which is advantageous for businesses in implementing and maintaining their business intelligence strategies.

    Kibana

    Disadvantages of Using Kibana for Business Intelligence

    Insufficient Documentation

    The lack of comprehensive documentation for Kibana plugins presents a significant challenge for users. Sparse information on plugin development and limitations can lead to increased development time and potential missteps in implementation.

    Limited Plugin Development Resources

    Without a centralized resource detailing extension points, developers may struggle to fully leverage the extensibility of Kibana. The absence of a comprehensive write-up on plugin limitations further complicates the development process for custom business intelligence features.

    Dependency on Examples

    To understand extension points and plugin capabilities, developers are often relegated to running example plugins. This indirect method of learning may hinder efficient adoption and use of Kibana for specialized business intelligence tasks.

    Kibana

    Frequently Asked Questions About Kibana

    What is Kibana used for?

    Kibana is used for visualizing Elasticsearch data, creating charts and dashboards, mapping geographic data, designing presentations, graphing patterns and relationships, modeling, predicting, and detecting behavior, generating and sharing reports, alerting and taking action, managing data and indices, configuring access and security, monitoring the Elastic Stack, investigating cases, troubleshooting, and organizing apps and objects with spaces.

    Can Kibana be used to monitor system performance?

    Yes, Kibana can be used to monitor the Elastic Stack, which includes monitoring system performance.

    How does Kibana handle security and access control?

    Kibana can be used to configure access and security, allowing management of who has access to what data and features within Kibana.

    Is it possible to generate reports with Kibana?

    Yes, Kibana can be used to generate and share reports based on Elasticsearch data.

    Can Kibana provide real-time alerts?

    Yes, Kibana can be used to alert and take action in real-time when specific conditions are met in the data.

    Use Cases for Kibana

    • Kibana

      Visualizing and reporting on business metrics such as clickstream data, website traffic, revenue, and sales data

    • Kibana

      Tracking and reporting on KPIs for internal company use at Elastic

    • Kibana

      Presenting business analytics data to senior management

    • Kibana

      Creating special visualizations for business data

    • Kibana

      Displaying business data in real-time using Canvas

    sourcetable

    Why Sourcetable is the Superior Choice for Business Intelligence

    Sourcetable offers a unique approach to business intelligence by integrating data from various services into a user-friendly spreadsheet interface. This contrasts with traditional analytics solutions like Qlikview, which, despite its robust features, can present a steeper learning curve for new users.

    • Streamlined Data Management

      With Sourcetable, data synchronization is simplified, enabling users to manage and analyze information without the complexity of an associative engine. This direct approach caters to businesses seeking immediate, actionable insights with minimal setup.

    • User-Friendly Interface

      The spreadsheet-like interface of Sourcetable is intuitive, putting business intelligence tools in the hands of users without specialized training. This democratization of data analytics is essential for businesses looking to empower their team members with decision-making capabilities.

    • Efficient Reporting

      Sourcetable's platform is designed for efficiency, streamlining the reporting process. Unlike Qlikview, which requires navigating through visual discovery and AI-powered insights, Sourcetable's straightforward design allows for quick generation of reports, fostering timely business decisions.

    • Centralized Collaboration

      Real-time collaboration is critical for modern businesses, and Sourcetable facilitates this through its centralized interface. This offers an advantage over Qlikview and Qlik Sense, where collaboration is possible but may not be as seamless for all users.

    Qlikview
    vs
    Kibana

    Comparison Between Qlikview and Kibana

    QlikView and Kibana are both data analytics and visualization solutions used for business intelligence. They enable organizations to visualize and derive insights from their data.

    Visual Discovery and Data Presentation

    QlikView offers intuitive visual discovery through its associative engine, similar to how Kibana allows users to create visualizations and dashboards. Both tools are designed to present data in a user-friendly manner, enabling more people within an organization to utilize business intelligence.

    Deployment Options

    QlikView can be deployed both as a cloud-based SaaS with Qlik Cloud Analytics and on-premises with Qlik Sense. Kibana, as part of the Elastic Stack, also offers flexibility in deployment, with options for cloud-based services or on-premises installations.

    Real-Time Collaboration

    Both QlikView and Kibana facilitate real-time collaboration and action, allowing teams to work together effectively on data analysis projects. This feature supports timely decision-making and insight sharing.

    Use of AI and Advanced Analytics

    QlikView utilizes AI to enhance human intuition and provide insights, a functionality that Kibana also seeks to offer through the integration of machine learning features within the Elastic Stack for advanced data analysis.

    Qlikview
    vs
    Kibana

    QlikView vs Kibana

    Deployment and Integration

    QlikView offers both cloud-based SaaS with Qlik Cloud Analytics and on-premises solutions with Qlik Sense. Kibana typically operates within the Elastic Stack for log and time-series analytics, primarily on cloud but can be deployed on-premises.

    Analytics and Data Processing

    QlikView uses an associative engine for data processing, allowing for intuitive visual discovery. Kibana, on the other hand, focuses on searching and visualizing data stored in Elasticsearch indices.

    User Interface and Experience

    QlikView provides an interface that supports visual discovery and business intelligence for a broad user base. Kibana offers a more specialized interface tailored to the exploration of Elasticsearch data.

    Artificial Intelligence and Collaboration

    QlikView and Qlik Sense enhance analytics with AI-powered insights and support real-time collaboration and action. Kibana does not inherently provide AI-powered insights but offers machine learning features as part of the Elastic Stack.

    Industry Application

    Qlik Sense is suitable for industries with strict data regulations due to its on-premises deployment. Kibana is generally used for IT operations, security, and application monitoring across various industries.

    sourcetable

    Comparison of QlikView, Kibana, and Sourcetable

    QlikView vs. Kibana

    QlikView is a comprehensive analytics solution that leverages an associative engine for data analysis, which differs from Kibana's focus on data visualization primarily for Elasticsearch data. QlikView's intuitive visual discovery and AI-powered insights support advanced data analytics, while Kibana offers robust visualization capabilities. QlikView's SaaS deployment contrasts with Kibana's typical on-premises or cloud deployment as part of the Elastic Stack. Real-time collaboration features in QlikView are not a primary focus of Kibana.

    QlikView vs. Sourcetable

    Sourcetable's features and capabilities are not specified in the provided facts, therefore a direct comparison to QlikView cannot be made solely based on the given information. Details about Sourcetable's engine, deployment model, collaboration capabilities, and use of AI would be necessary for an accurate comparison.

    Kibana vs. Sourcetable

    Without specific facts about Sourcetable, it is not possible to offer a comparison to Kibana. Understanding Sourcetable's data visualization, analysis capabilities, deployment options, and potential integration with data sources would be essential to evaluate these two tools against each other.

    sourcetable

    Frequently Asked Questions About Sourcetable

    What is Sourcetable and who typically uses it?

    Sourcetable is a spreadsheet application that allows users to access data from most 3rd party applications, query data, and build live models that automatically update. It is typically used by growth teams and business operations teams.

    How does Sourcetable replace traditional workflows?

    Sourcetable replaces workflows that are typically done in Excel, Google Sheets, and Business Intelligence tools by centralizing, analyzing, and modeling data that updates over time, without requiring any coding.

    What are the pricing plans for Sourcetable and what do they include?

    Sourcetable costs $50 per month for the starter plan and $250 per month for the pro plan. All plans have a 14-day free trial. The starter plan includes the first 5 users, and each additional seat costs $20 per month.

    How frequently does Sourcetable update its data integrations?

    Data integrations update every 15 minutes on the regular plan and every 5 minutes on the pro plan.

    Is coding required to use Sourcetable?

    No, coding is not required to use Sourcetable.

    Qlikview

    Qlikview Pricing Plans

    • Standard Plan

      The Qlikview Standard Plan mandates a minimum subscription for 20 full users. It is inclusive of 25 GB/year for data analysis, with capabilities to integrate and process data from hundreds of sources. The plan features interactive data visualizations, dashboards, and augmented analytics leveraged by AI. Collaboration within a team and around-the-clock customer support are also provided.

    • Premium Plan

      Qlikview's Premium Plan extends the Standard Plan by doubling the data analysis capacity to 50 GB/year. It includes additional features such as automated report generation, predictive analytics with automated machine learning, and no-code automation builder triggers. Subscribers benefit from added data governance and a personalized customer success plan.

    • Enterprise Plan

      The Enterprise Plan is designed for extensive data analysis, offering 500 GB/year. It encompasses all the benefits of the Premium Plan, catering to larger organizations that require robust data governance and extensive predictive analytics capabilities.

    • Capacity Alerts

      Qlikview proactively notifies users as they near their data capacity limit, ensuring uninterrupted service and data management.

    Kibana

    Kibana Pricing Overview

    Kibana pricing initiates at a monthly rate of $95. Costs escalate contingent upon data usage and the number of operational zones. A trial version of Kibana is available at no cost.

    • Cost Factors

    • Base price starts at $95/month.
    • Scaling costs depend on data volume and zone count.

    • Trial Offer

      Kibana offers a free trial period for evaluation purposes.

    Qlikview

    User Reviews and Ratings of QlikView

    • Overall Impressions

      QlikView has garnered an overall rating of 4.3, reflecting generally positive user sentiment. The software is praised for its functionality, with a 4.5 rating, and users find it versatile for data visualization and complex report creation. However, it falls short in response times with heavy data volume and real-time data sync.

    • Usability

      Users find QlikView to have a 4 rating for both ease-of-use and customer support, indicating satisfactory but not exceptional performance in these areas. The value for money also stands at a 4 rating. Some users find the user interface clunky and the tool less user-friendly with certain data sources.

    • Functionality

    • QlikView is recognized as a powerful BI tool, useful for creating sales and inventory dashboards.
    • Its data visualization capabilities are appreciated but not seen as the best available.
    • Despite being easy to implement and fast, it lacks R integration and is not ideal for detailed reporting.
    • QlikView's in-memory processing and ability to schedule batch jobs for ETL are noted features.

    • Limitations

    • Users report that QlikView does not allow exporting of a list of all currently licensed users.
    • The tool is not capable of write-back to the database.
    • When compared to Qlik Sense, Tableau, and PowerBI, QlikView is perceived as less capable.

    • Community and Support

      QlikView has a wide user group over the internet and offers a support forum, which is beneficial for problem-solving and peer assistance. It is also mentioned as being great for students writing a thesis.

    • Cost Consideration

      Although QlikView provides significant value and is free in its basic version, it is considered expensive, potentially affecting its overall cost-effectiveness for some users.

    Kibana

    User Reviews and Ratings of Kibana

    • Positive Feedback

      Users appreciate Kibana for its strong data visualization capabilities, particularly its customizability and report formatting templates. Its capacity to discover and visualize data efficiently is also highlighted positively. Enterprises commonly utilize Kibana to monitor production environments, visualize automated error reports, and understand request flows through applications. The tool's customizability is often praised, reflecting its ability to tailor dashboards and reports to specific needs.

    • Area of Complexity

    • Kibana's search and filter functionalities can be complex for some users, indicating a potential need for simplification or better user guidance.
    • The lack of out-of-the-box dashboards and reports has been noted by some users, suggesting a preference for more ready-to-use features upon initial setup.
    • There is a learning curve associated with the initial installation of Kibana, which could be daunting for new users.
    • A heavy operational workload is reported with the use of Kibana, pointing to the resource intensiveness of the tool.

    • User Ratings

      The reviews indicate that Kibana excels in several key areas, receiving perfect scores in customizability, ad-hoc reporting, drill-down analysis, formatting capabilities, and report sharing and collaboration. These ratings are based on user feedback and underscore the tool's comprehensive functionality in these domains.

    Conclusion

    In summary, Qlikview offers robust data modeling and analytics capabilities, suitable for complex business intelligence needs. Kibana, on the other hand, excels in data visualization and is particularly strong when integrated with Elasticsearch for log and time-series data analysis.

    For those seeking a more user-friendly and integrated approach, Sourcetable provides a solution that simplifies business intelligence. It syncs data in real-time across various services into a spreadsheet interface, making it accessible for users familiar with spreadsheets.

    Recommended Reading



    Simplify Your BI Tooling

    Sourcetable is the AI spreadsheet that lets you analyze your data in one place. Get unlimited access free for 14 days.


    Try out Sourcetable
    Drop CSV