Power BI
tool icon

Power BI vs Cognos: An In-Depth Comparison

Jump to

    Introduction

    When it comes to business intelligence, choosing the right tool is crucial for efficient data analysis and reporting. Power BI and Cognos are both robust solutions, each with its own strengths and user base.

    Power BI is known for its user-friendly interface and deep integration with Microsoft products, while Cognos offers advanced analytics capabilities and extensive customization options.

    This comparison will delve into the features, usability, and scalability of both platforms. Moreover, we'll explore how Sourcetable provides a modernized, spreadsheet-like interface that syncs with your data as an alternative for business intelligence tasks like reporting and data analytics.

    Power BI

    What is Power BI?

    Power BI is a comprehensive collection of software services, apps, and connectors designed to transform disparate data sources into visually immersive and interactive business intelligence insights. It caters to diverse data environments, including Excel spreadsheets, as well as cloud-based and on-premises hybrid data warehouses.

    • Core Elements

    • Power BI Desktop: An essential tool for creating detailed reports and publishing them to Power BI Service.
    • Power BI Service: A SaaS service that facilitates the creation, sharing, and consumption of business insights.
    • Power BI Mobile Apps: Enable monitoring of business progress and embedding of dashboards into custom applications.

    • Additional Features

    • Power BI Report Builder: Tailored for constructing paginated reports.
    • Power BI Report Server: Offers on-premises report deployment and management, integrating with cloud services.

    • Integration and Administration

      Power BI is seamlessly integrated with Microsoft Fabric, enhancing data analysis and visualization capabilities. The administration of Power BI is also streamlined through Microsoft Fabric, supporting efficient management within large organizations.

    • Flexibility and Accessibility

      Power BI's flexibility makes it a compelling choice for individuals across various roles, providing tailored insights and features that cater to specific business needs. It supports both individual and collaborative work, ensuring that insights can be shared with anyone or everyone as needed.

    tool icon

    What is Cognos?

    Cognos is a business intelligence tool developed by IBM. It employs artificial intelligence to generate visualizations and dashboards for data analysis. The tool offers flexible deployment options, with availability on-premises or on the cloud. Cognos provides a cost-effective solution for businesses, with plans starting at $10.60 per month per user. Additionally, IBM offers a trial version of Cognos, allowing potential users to evaluate the tool's capabilities for free.

    Power BI

    Power BI Features

    Data Connectivity and Visualization

    Power BI provides capabilities for users to connect to various data sources and create visual representations. This feature supports the transformation of raw data into intelligible insights.

    Integration with Applications

    Users can integrate Power BI visuals into their everyday applications. This ensures that insights are readily available in familiar work environments, enhancing productivity.

    Insights and Impact

    Power BI enables users to discover insights within their data. These insights can be leveraged to drive impactful decisions across business functions.

    Support and Interaction

    Power BI includes chat support, offering users direct assistance and enhancing the overall user experience.

    tool icon

    Key Features of Cognos Analytics

    Data Modeling and Integration

    Cognos Analytics is a robust web-based tool facilitating data modeling. It allows for various data operations such as upload, connection, joining, and modeling, enabling users to integrate and transform data effectively.

    Visualization and Reporting

    Interactive dashboards and advanced enterprise reporting are central to Cognos Analytics. These features provide dynamic visualization options for data presentation and dissemination.

    Advanced Analytics

    The platform incorporates predictive forecasting and decision trees. It leverages artificial intelligence to enhance data analysis, leading to more informed decision-making processes.

    Artificial Intelligence Capabilities

    Cognos Analytics integrates AI to expedite data preparation, automate exploration, and ensure data protection. These AI features streamline analytics workflows and reinforce data governance.

    Power BI

    Benefits of Power BI Pro for Business Intelligence

    Enhanced Collaboration and Sharing

    Power BI Pro enhances business intelligence by enabling interactive data visualizations and insights to be shared across teams and with stakeholders. Integration with Microsoft Teams, Dynamics 365, and Power Platform streamlines this process.

    Self-Service Analytics

    Self-service analytics empower users to analyze data independently, utilizing low-code or no-code tools for data preparation, contributing to efficient decision-making.

    Comprehensive Data Connectivity

    The ability to connect to any data source and add data to the OneLake data hub ensures comprehensive access to data for analytics, providing a holistic view of business operations.

    Insight Discovery with AI

    Advanced generative AI in Power BI Pro aids in uncovering deeper insights, enhancing reporting and data analysis outcomes.

    Data Governance and Security

    Secure governance of data is a key advantage, ensuring that sensitive information is managed responsibly within the business intelligence framework.

    Unified Access

    Microsoft Fabric provides a unified access point for all business intelligence resources, simplifying navigation and usage for users.

    Familiarity and Ease of Use

    The use of familiar tools within Power BI Pro reduces the learning curve, facilitating adoption and productivity in reporting and analytics tasks.

    Power BI

    Disadvantages of Power BI for Business Intelligence

    Usability Challenges

    Power BI presents a steep learning curve, making it challenging for new users to quickly adapt and utilize its full capabilities for reporting and data analytics. This barrier can delay the integration of business intelligence processes within an organization.

    Customization and Compatibility Limitations

    Limited customization options in Power BI restrict the ability to tailor reports and dashboards to specific business needs. Compatibility issues with non-Microsoft applications further constrain its utility in diverse IT environments.

    Data Management and Performance

    Power BI may encounter performance issues with large datasets and has restrictions on the amount of data that can be loaded, which can impede the analysis of extensive data collections. Additionally, the lack of in-memory data processing can slow down data manipulation tasks.

    Integration and Support for Data Types

    The application's ability to support specialized data sources or data types is not comprehensive, potentially excluding certain datasets from being analyzed. This limitation can affect businesses relying on niche or proprietary data.

    Visual and Security Constraints

    Power BI offers limited visual customization, hindering the creation of highly tailored visual representations of data. Limited data security options can raise concerns for businesses with stringent data governance and compliance requirements.

    Editor and Interface Shortcomings

    The slow query editor in Power BI can hamper the speed at which data analysts can interact with data, while the outdated user interface may not meet modern aesthetic and usability standards.

    Data Integrity and Formatting

    When integrating with Excel, Power BI has known data integrity issues, which can affect the accuracy of reports. Limited visual formatting options also restrict the ability to present data analytics in the most effective way.

    Power BI

    Frequently Asked Questions About Power BI

    What is Power BI?

    Power BI is a cloud-based business analytics service that allows users to visualize and analyze data from a variety of sources.

    What are the different versions of Power BI?

    The main versions of Power BI are Power BI Desktop, a free application for creating reports, Power BI Pro, a paid version which allows full access to all content and capabilities in the service including sharing and collaboration, and Power BI Premium, which provides more consistent performance and supports larger data volumes for enterprise needs.

    How do I get started with Power BI?

    Business users need a web browser and email to get started using Power BI. Power BI Desktop can be downloaded for free for report creation, and native apps are available for Android, iOS, and Windows 10 devices.

    Does Power BI support mobile devices?

    Yes, Power BI native apps are available for Android, iOS, and Windows 10 devices.

    How can I undo an action in Power BI?

    To undo an action in Power BI, you can press Ctrl+Z.

    Use Cases for Power BI

    • Power BI

      Personal BI for individual data analysis and reporting

    • Power BI

      Departmental BI to distribute insights within a specific business unit

    • Power BI

      Managed self-service BI for report creators to utilize and share semantic models

    • Power BI

      Enterprise content publishing to programmatically distribute content at scale

    • Power BI

      Embedding Power BI visuals into applications for customer-facing analytics

    tool icon

    Advantages of Using Cognos for Business Intelligence

    Comprehensive BI Suite

    Cognos offers a full-featured business intelligence suite that supports the entire analytics cycle, from data preparation to reporting. Its robust architecture is designed for larger deployments, handling large and complex data with ease.

    Data Analytics and Reporting

    With Cognos, users gain significant productivity gains through advanced automation and AI assistance. It excels in statistical analysis, predictive modeling, and operational reporting, delivering reports via email or publishing to websites as required.

    Self-Service Capabilities

    Self-service features empower users to develop dashboards and reports without extensive technical knowledge. The AI Assistant enhances this by aiding in tasks like data analysis, data prep, and report generation using plain English commands.

    Security and Governance

    Cognos provides advanced security controls, including row and role level security, multi-factor authentication, and data governance, ensuring data integrity and compliance across the organization.

    Integration and Scalability

    Seamless integration with both IBM and third-party products, along with the ability to connect to multiple data sources, makes Cognos a versatile tool. Its scalability meets the growing demands of businesses.

    Collaboration and Reduced Dependency

    Cognos fosters efficient collaboration among team members and reduces the dependency on isolated developers, streamlining the BI process within the organization.

    tool icon

    Disadvantages of Using Cognos for Business Intelligence

    Integration and Functionality Limitations

    Cognos exhibits limited API integration, which can pose challenges in extending its capabilities and connecting with other systems. The platform lacks in several advanced AI functionalities, such as automated dashboard creation, data governance controls, row level security, and multi-factor authentication, thus requiring additional tools and manual effort to manage these aspects.

    User Experience Challenges

    The user interface of Cognos is considered clunky and not modern, contributing to a steep learning curve for beginners. Performance issues emerge, particularly with large datasets, and the resource consumption is high, impacting overall system efficiency. Additionally, the mobile experience offered by Cognos falls short compared to the desktop version.

    Support and Community

    Customer support for Cognos is not at par with industry standards, and the platform also lacks robust community support. This can lead to difficulties in troubleshooting and getting help for users, which is compounded by the presence of many minor bugs within the system.

    Cost and Resource Considerations

    The cost of implementing and maintaining Cognos is significant, making it an expensive option for business intelligence. The software is resource-intensive, particularly in CPU usage, which may necessitate investment in more powerful hardware or cloud services.

    Data Management and Security

    Cognos does not offer in-built data cleansing, leaving data preparation to be handled at the source or through external tools. Additionally, the lack of advanced security features like multi-factor authentication and row level security can be a concern for organizations with stringent data security and governance requirements.

    Additional Technical Concerns

  • Cognos is not as widely adopted as competitors like Qlik and Tableau, potentially affecting the availability of skilled professionals.
  • The administration interface and video quality need enhancements for better manageability and user engagement.
  • Maps and visualizations, alongside cloud deployment options, require improvements to meet current business intelligence standards.
    • tool icon

    Frequently Asked Questions About Cognos

    Which web browsers support Cognos?

    Cognos is supported on different web browsers but does not support all Studios in Chrome or Safari.

    Can I customize the view in Cognos to make data more readable?

    Yes, users can alternate the shading of each line in Cognos to enhance readability.

    How do I access restricted data in Cognos?

    Cognos requires that users request permission to view certain data.

    What is the purpose of Cognos AP Data?

    Cognos AP Data is for reconciliations and helps to determine which invoices have been processed, when checks will be cut, and if checks have been mailed.

    How can I retrieve scanned invoices using Cognos?

    Cognos AP Doc Viewer is used to retrieve scanned invoices.

    Use Cases for Cognos

    • tool icon

      Developing analytics solutions

    • tool icon

      Making data-driven decisions

    • tool icon

      Optimizing supply chains

    • tool icon

      Analyzing sales and marketing data

    • tool icon

      Forecasting business trends

    sourcetable

    Why Sourcetable is the Superior Choice for Business Intelligence

    • Simplified Reporting

      Sourcetable offers a streamlined approach to reporting by integrating data from various services into a user-friendly spreadsheet interface. Unlike Power BI and Cognos, which may have steeper learning curves, Sourcetable's intuitive design makes it accessible for users of all skill levels.

    • Enhanced Data Analytics

      With its ability to sync data across multiple platforms, Sourcetable provides a comprehensive view of business analytics. This consolidation of data sources into one interface surpasses the capabilities of Power BI and Cognos by minimizing the complexity of data analysis.

    • Unified Data Integration

      The platform excels in unifying data streams, offering a singular solution for data management. Sourcetable's spreadsheet-like interface allows for seamless data integration, in contrast to Power BI's and Cognos's more segmented data visualization and app infusion features.

    Power BI
    vs
    tool icon

    Similarities between Power BI and Cognos

    Both Power BI and Cognos are business intelligence tools that offer robust data connectivity. They enable users to connect to various data sources, ensuring diverse datasets can be integrated and analyzed. This capacity for data connectivity is a cornerstone feature of both platforms, catering to the need for comprehensive data analysis in today's information-driven business environments.

    Power BI
    vs
    tool icon

    Differences Between Power BI and Cognos

    Data Connectivity and Visualization

    Power BI offers capabilities to connect to and visualize any data, which is a prominent feature that may differ from Cognos' data handling capabilities. Cognos might have limitations or different processes for data integration and visualization.

    Infusing Visuals into Apps

    Power BI provides the functionality to infuse visuals into everyday apps, enhancing the accessibility of data analytics. This integration feature may contrast with Cognos' approach to embedding analytics into applications.

    sourcetable

    Power BI vs. Cognos vs. Sourcetable Comparison

    Connectivity and Data Visualization

    Power BI: Offers the capacity to connect to various data sources and create visualizations.

    Cognos: IBM Cognos also allows for data connectivity but focuses on enterprise-level reporting and analytics.

    Sourcetable: Simplifies data work by combining spreadsheets with database capabilities but may not support as wide a range of data sources as Power BI.

    Integration with Applications

    Power BI: Enables embedding of visuals into commonly used applications for streamlined analytics.

    Cognos: Provides dashboards and reports that can be integrated into business applications, though it might be less flexible than Power BI in embedding visuals.

    Sourcetable: Focuses on data collaboration within its platform and may not offer the same level of application integration for visual infusion.

    User Focus and Accessibility

    Power BI: Targets both non-technical users and data professionals with its user-friendly interface.

    Cognos: Caters to enterprise users with a need for robust reporting tools and may have a steeper learning curve.

    Sourcetable: Aims to make data tasks accessible to users familiar with spreadsheets, potentially offering a lower barrier to entry than Cognos.

    sourcetable

    Frequently Asked Questions About Sourcetable

    What is Sourcetable and who typically uses it?

    Sourcetable is a spreadsheet application that replaces workflows done in Excel, Google Sheets, and Business Intelligence tools. It is typically used by growth teams and business operations teams.

    Does Sourcetable require any coding skills?

    No, Sourcetable does not require any coding skills to use.

    How does Sourcetable handle data integrations and updates?

    Sourcetable syncs data from over 100 applications and most databases. Data integrations update every 15 minutes on the regular plan and every 5 minutes on the pro plan.

    What are the pricing plans for Sourcetable?

    Sourcetable is $50 per month on the starter plan and $250 per month on the pro plan. Additional seats cost $20 per month per seat.

    Is there a trial period for Sourcetable?

    Yes, all plans come with a 14-day free trial.

    Power BI

    Power BI Cost Overview

    • Power BI Licensing Options

      Power BI offers different licensing options tailored for varying business needs. Power BI Pro is priced at $10 per user/month, suitable for business users requiring collaboration capabilities. Power BI Premium provides more dedicated resources and advanced features, with per user pricing at $20 per user/month and capacity pricing starting at $4,995 per month for a P1 SKU.

    • Additional Power BI Costs

      Users can also opt for add-on licenses at $10 per user/month. For scalable compute resources, Autoscale is available at $85 per vCore/24hours. Fabric SKUs, such as F64 and higher, offer cost-effective alternatives for large-scale Power BI deployments, costing $5,002.67 per month for an F64 (P1 equivalent) license and $8,409.60 per month for an F64 SKU (P1 equivalent) license.

    • Content Consumption Without Extra Licenses

      Power BI ensures broad accessibility to reports and dashboards. With Power BI Premium per capacity SKUs P1 and higher, as well as Fabric SKUs F64 and above, all users can consume Power BI content without the need for additional paid per-user licenses.

    • Complementary Power BI Services

      Power BI Desktop, Power BI Embedded, and Power BI Mobile apps are available at no cost, providing free access to basic data visualization and reporting capabilities.

    • Purchase Methods

    • Power BI Pro and Premium per user licenses can be purchased directly by users for self-service or through the Microsoft 365 admin center.
    • Power BI Premium per capacity and Fabric SKUs require purchase through the Microsoft 365 admin center.
    • A credit card can be used for purchasing Power BI Pro and Premium per user licenses.
    • Access to the Microsoft 365 admin center is necessary to purchase any Power BI services.
    tool icon

    Cognos Cost Overview

    • Cognos Analytics on Cloud

      Cognos Analytics on Cloud is priced at USD 10.60 per user per month. Designed for smaller teams and organizations, it operates within a multi-tenant SaaS environment managed by IBM.

    • Cognos Analytics on-premises

      Cognos Analytics on-premises is available for USD 42.40 per user per month, with a user limit up to 200. This solution is suited for teams requiring secure access to on-premises or cloud data sources and who prioritize the latest product innovations. Offerings include a standalone software package and a Cognos cartridge for Cloud Pak for Data. It allows for full system administration control and is available on IBM marketplace for deployment on-premises or on a preferred cloud virtual infrastructure. Users are responsible for managing the hardware, operating system, and application.

    Power BI

    User Reviews of Power BI

    • General Feedback

      Users regard Power BI as one of the best BI tools on the market, highlighting its exceptional data visualization capabilities and wide array of data connectors. It is celebrated for its user-friendly interface and its familiarity to those accustomed to Microsoft products, contributing to a shorter learning curve. The platform is noted for being an optimal choice for both seasoned and novice data analysts.

    • Versions and Pricing

      The availability of a free version of Power BI is often mentioned, though it comes with limitations in data storage and refresh cycles. The Professional version, aimed at enterprises, offers expanded storage, faster data refreshes, and collaboration features, distinguishing it as a more robust solution for larger scale operations.

    • Connectivity and Integration

      With 74 data connectors, including popular ones like MailChimp and Salesforce, users appreciate the ease of integrating diverse data sources into their analytics workflows. The connectors are highlighted for enabling seamless incorporation of data from various apps or datasets into Power BI queries.

    • Advanced Features

      Additional modules such as Power BI Gateway - Personal are recognized for facilitating secure data transfer between on-premises data and the cloud-based Power BI service. The Publish to web feature is also noted, allowing users to make their reports and visualizations public.

    • Customization and Ease of Use

      Power BI's high level of customization through a variety of custom visualizations available from the Office Store is often mentioned in reviews. Users also commend the simplicity of the data loading process and the highly intuitive UI, which make Power BI a powerful tool for business analysts.

    tool icon

    User Reviews of Cognos

    According to top business intelligence review websites, Cognos is recognized as a robust business intelligence tool. It excels in data analysis, visualization, and reporting. Users appreciate its user-friendly interface, good reporting features, and dashboards. Many point out that while Cognos is rich in capabilities and supports a variety of data sources, it can be complex to fully master.

    • Integration and Analytics

      Cognos is praised for its seamless integration with other IBM analytics products and its powerful business analytics capabilities. It is considered an excellent tool for analyzing large volumes of data. Despite its complexity, users find it relatively easy to implement and use.

    • Accessibility and Support

      The tool includes a mobile version which enhances its accessibility for users on the go. Customer service for Cognos is rated positively, providing users with the support they need.

    • Challenges and Considerations

    • Cognos is noted to be expensive and may represent a significant investment for small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs).
    • Some users find Cognos difficult to set up, with a notably slow startup on Windows services.
    • Creating reports can be challenging, with users often requiring significant resources or an expert for full functionality implementation.
    • Novice users report difficulties with the learning curve involved in using Cognos effectively.

    • Summary

      In summary, Cognos is considered a reliable and complete business intelligence package, especially suited for large enterprises. Despite being a self-service BI software, the need for expert knowledge to unlock its full potential is a common theme among users.

    Conclusion

    Both Power BI and Cognos offer robust business intelligence capabilities, each with its own strengths. Power BI is known for its deep integration with other Microsoft services, while Cognos provides powerful analytics with a focus on enterprise-level reporting.

    However, for those seeking a more streamlined approach, Sourcetable offers a solution. It syncs data across all services in real-time and presents it within a familiar spreadsheet interface, simplifying the business intelligence process.

    Recommended Reading



    Simplify Your BI Tooling

    Sourcetable is the AI spreadsheet that lets you analyze your data in one place. Get unlimited access free for 14 days.


    Please use a work email