Google Looker
tool icon

Google Looker vs Airflow: An In-Depth Comparison

Jump to

    Introduction

    Choosing the right tool for business intelligence and data analytics is crucial for effective decision-making. Google Looker and Apache Airflow are two powerful platforms that serve distinct purposes; Looker for data exploration and business intelligence, and Airflow for workflow automation.

    While both tools offer valuable features, they cater to different aspects of data handling and have unique strengths. It's important to understand how they compare in terms of functionality, ease of use, and integration capabilities.

    In the following sections, we'll delve into the specifics of Google Looker and Airflow, and introduce Sourcetable as a contemporary solution that combines the ease of a spreadsheet interface with robust data synchronization, offering an alternative approach to business intelligence tasks.

    Google Looker

    What is Google Looker?

    Google Looker is a business intelligence (BI) platform that is part of the Google Cloud product suite. It enables users to access, analyze, and utilize their data effectively. As a cloud-based solution, Looker provides the flexibility and convenience of managing data workloads and analytics on the cloud.

    • Core Features

    • Looker facilitates the analysis of data, allowing users to derive actionable insights and make data-informed decisions.
    • It provides the capability to create data experiences tailored to the needs of different business scenarios.
    • Users can interact with their business data through an integrated chat feature, enhancing real-time collaboration and decision-making.
    • The platform incorporates generative AI, which supports the development of applications that are empowered by data.
    • Looker offers a self-service model that promotes data governance, enabling users to maintain control over their data environment.
    • Integration and Customization

      Google Looker supports the integration with existing BI tools, allowing businesses to leverage Looker's modeling capabilities within their current environment. Additionally, it provides the tools necessary for building custom applications with trusted metrics, ensuring consistency and reliability in data reporting and analysis.

    tool icon

    What is Airflow

    Apache Airflow is an open-source platform designed for orchestrating complex computational workflows and data processing pipelines. Developed by Apache, it enables the development, scheduling, and monitoring of batch-oriented workflows.

    Google Looker

    Google Looker Features

    Business Intelligence Capabilities

    Looker is a business intelligence (BI) tool providing enterprise-class solutions. It delivers a fresh, consistent, and governed real-time view of data, enabling proactive insights.

    Data Management and Modeling

    Utilizing LookML, a SQL-based modeling language, Looker enables analysts to define and manage business rules centrally. Looker's data model is version-controlled with Git, ensuring robust data governance.

    Integration and Accessibility

    Looker integrates seamlessly with Looker Studio and is a core product within the Google Cloud ecosystem. Accessible through the Google Cloud console, it offers robust APIs and prebuilt integrations, facilitating a unified analytics experience.

    Data Visualization and Reporting

    The platform simplifies the creation of reports and dashboards, making data analysis and visualization accessible. Users can connect to Looker's semantic model to explore and visualize data with Looker Studio.

    Cloud Infrastructure and Service Availability

    Built on Google Cloud infrastructure, Looker is available as a service within the Google Cloud, benefiting from the security and performance of Google's cloud offerings.

    tool icon

    Key Features of Airflow

    Scalability and Architecture

    Airflow features a modular architecture and uses a message queue to orchestrate workers, enabling it to scale seamlessly.

    Pipeline Definition and Generation

    Pipelines in Airflow are defined in Python, allowing for dynamic generation and instantiation of workflows.

    Extensibility and Integration

    With extensible design, Airflow can be tailored to fit specific environments by extending its libraries. It also integrates easily with third-party services through plug-and-play operators.

    Usability and Monitoring

    Airflow's modern web application facilitates efficient monitoring, scheduling, and workflow management. Its Python-based foundation makes it accessible for anyone with Python expertise to deploy workflows.

    Templating and Customization

    Utilizing the Jinja templating engine, Airflow allows parametrization for pipelines, promoting lean and explicit workflow definitions.

    Open Source Community

    As an open-source project, Airflow benefits from community-driven development and support.

    Google Looker

    Advantages of Google Looker for Business Intelligence

    Enterprise Business Intelligence

    Looker Studio Pro serves as a robust enterprise business intelligence tool, catering to the needs of medium and large scale environments.

    Data Exploration and Visualization

    This platform enables users to delve into data analysis, create visualizations, and respond to business queries efficiently.

    Collaboration and Content Management

    With features tailored for team content management and collaboration, Looker Studio Pro facilitates sharing insights and dashboards among team members.

    Enterprise Support Access

    Users benefit from dedicated enterprise support, ensuring reliable assistance for complex business intelligence tasks.

    Google Looker

    Disadvantages of Using Google Looker

    Connectivity and Migration Issues

    Lacks connectivity connection.Migrating data from AWS to BigQuery was painful.

  • Lacks connectivity connection.
  • Migrating data from AWS to BigQuery was painful.
  • User Experience Challenges

    The platform is slow and not very intuitive.Looker is laggy, especially when handling many graphs on one page.

  • The platform is slow and not very intuitive.
  • Looker is laggy, especially when handling many graphs on one page.
  • Complex Usability

    Users face a steep learning curve with Google Looker.Sharing mechanisms are complex and not user-friendly.

  • Users face a steep learning curve with Google Looker.
  • Sharing mechanisms are complex and not user-friendly.
  • Cost and Accessibility Concerns

    Onboarding is expensive.Access can be heavily restricted by security teams.

  • Onboarding is expensive.
  • Access can be heavily restricted by security teams.
  • Documentation and Training

    Training materials and documentation are not easily available.

  • Training materials and documentation are not easily available.
  • Google Looker

    Frequently Asked Questions About Google Looker

    What are the hours for Looker Support in Japanese?

    Support in Japanese is available from 9:00 AM JST to 5:00 PM JST, Monday through Friday, and from 5:00 PM JST to 9:00 AM JST, Monday through Saturday, including weekends and holidays.

    How do I ensure my Looker instance is eligible for support?

    Your Looker instance must be running an officially supported version. Instances hosted by Looker automatically update to supported releases, but customer-hosted instances must manually update if they are running an unsupported version.

    What do I need to do to receive Looker Support for my Looker (original) instance?

    For Looker (original) instances, you need to fill in the Google Cloud Project number on the Admin General Settings page to receive Looker Support.

    Who is eligible to receive Looker Support?

    Looker Support is available to users with the Tech Support Editor IAM role and to administrators and developers on instances using Legacy Support.

    What might I be prompted to do when submitting a Looker support request?

    You may be prompted to choose from a product area when submitting a support request.

    Use Cases for Google Looker

    • Google Looker

      Reducing client report time

    • Google Looker

      Modernizing business intelligence

    • Google Looker

      Embedding analytics in platforms

    tool icon

    Advantages of Using Airflow Pros for Business Intelligence Tasks

    There are no facts provided that relate directly to the use of Airflow Pros for business intelligence tasks like reporting and data analytics. Please provide relevant facts to include in this section.

    tool icon

    Disadvantages of Using Airflow in Business Intelligence

    Programming Skills Requirement

    Implementing Airflow for business intelligence tasks necessitates programming expertise. This creates a barrier to entry for teams without coding experience, potentially limiting the adoption of Airflow in environments where programming is not a core skill.

    Complex Setup

    The need for extensive component setup with Airflow presents a significant disadvantage. The initial configuration and management of these components can be time-consuming and complex, hindering quick deployment in business intelligence scenarios.

    Steep Learning Curve

    Airflow's challenging learning curve can slow down the integration process within business intelligence frameworks. Employees may require additional training and time to become proficient, delaying the realization of analytics insights.

    Limited Documentation

    Inadequate documentation for Airflow further complicates its use for reporting and data analytics. With less guidance available, users may struggle to troubleshoot issues or leverage advanced features, affecting productivity and effectiveness.

    tool icon

    Frequently Asked Questions About Airflow

    Why am I seeing low DAG scheduling latency with Airflow 2.0?

    Airflow 2.0 has low DAG scheduling latency out of the box, providing efficient scheduling performance without additional configuration.

    How can I improve the throughput of my Airflow instance?

    To increase throughput, you can start multiple schedulers. This allows Airflow to handle more tasks concurrently.

    What can I do if I encounter a TemplateNotFound error in Airflow?

    A TemplateNotFound error is typically due to not correctly specifying the path to an operator that uses Jinja templating. Make sure the files are correctly located relative to the pipeline file or add additional directories to the template_searchpath of the DAG object.

    Why is my task failing with no logs showing in the UI?

    A task may fail with no logs in the UI if the task's worker was unable to write logs or if the task got stuck in a queued state.

    Is it possible to trigger an Airflow task based on the failure of another task?

    Yes, you can use Trigger Rules to trigger tasks based on another task's failure. For example, ALL_FAILED triggers when all upstream tasks have failed, and ONE_FAILED triggers when at least one upstream task has failed.

    Use Cases for Airflow

    • tool icon

      ETL/ELT analytics

    • tool icon

      Infrastructure management for BI tools

    • tool icon

      Scheduling and automation of report generation

    sourcetable

    Comparing Sourcetable to Google Looker and Airflow for Business Intelligence

    • Simplified Reporting and Analytics

      Sourcetable offers a streamlined solution for reporting and analytics by integrating data from multiple services into a user-friendly, spreadsheet-like interface. This contrasts with Google Looker, which, while powerful, may have a steeper learning curve for self-service BI and governed BI.

    • Unified Data Syncing

      Unlike Google Looker and Airflow, which require more complex data modeling and workflow building, Sourcetable simplifies the process by syncing all data into one accessible location. This ease of data consolidation is advantageous for businesses looking to act on their data efficiently.

    • Accessibility for Non-Technical Users

      The spreadsheet-like interface of Sourcetable is inherently familiar to most users, reducing the barrier to entry for non-technical stakeholders. This accessibility is a key differentiator from Looker's embedded analytics and data modeling features, which may require more specialized knowledge.

    • Integration Versatility

      Sourcetable's ability to integrate with various services ensures that it is a versatile tool for businesses looking to combine different data sources. This can be more advantageous than using Google Looker for organizational BI, which may not offer the same level of integration simplicity.

    • Efficiency in Data Operations

      By streamlining the data syncing process, Sourcetable facilitates quicker and more efficient data operations compared to Google Looker's approach to building data-powered applications and workflows. This efficiency can lead to faster insights and actions.

    Google Looker
    vs
    tool icon

    Comparing Google Looker and Airflow

    The comparison between Google Looker and Airflow highlights their roles in data management and processing. While Google Looker is a business intelligence platform, Airflow is an open-source workflow management system. Both tools are designed to help organizations utilize their data more effectively.

    Workflow and Automation

    Google Looker and Airflow facilitate the creation of workflows. Looker allows users to build workflows and applications to leverage business intelligence. Similarly, Airflow automates the scheduling and running of complex data workflows. Both systems contribute to streamlining processes within an organization.

    Data Operations

    Both platforms are used to manage and operationalize data. Looker provides embedded data modeling and can be used for organizational business intelligence, while Airflow's purpose is to programmatically author, schedule, and monitor workflows, often involving data tasks.

    Integration Capabilities

    Google Looker and Airflow can be integrated into various systems to enhance data analysis and operations. Looker's embedded analytics applications and Airflow's ability to work with multiple data sources and processing engines make them flexible for different data environments.

    Google Looker
    vs
    tool icon

    Google Looker vs. Airflow

    Business Intelligence vs. Workflow Automation

    Google Looker is a business intelligence platform facilitating data analysis and application development. It allows for self-service and governed BI, enabling organizations to access, analyze, and act on data. In contrast, Airflow is not a business intelligence platform; it is a tool for scheduling and orchestrating complex computational workflows.

    Data Applications and Embedded Analytics

    Looker provides capabilities for building data-powered applications and embedded analytics. It supports embedded data modeling and can be used to deliver trusted data experiences. Airflow, on the other hand, does not offer features for embedded analytics or data application development.

    Generative AI and Data Interaction

    Google Looker includes a generative AI feature and enables users to interact with business data through chat. Airflow does not have a generative AI feature and is not designed for interactive data analysis or chat-based data interaction.

    Use Case Focus

    Looker is designed to serve organizational and self-service business intelligence needs, allowing for the creation of workflows and applications within the BI context. Airflow is focused on automating scripts and tasks as part of data processing pipelines, without inherent business intelligence capabilities.

    sourcetable

    Comparison of Google Looker, Airflow, and Sourcetable

    Google Looker

    Google Looker is a comprehensive business intelligence platform that provides self-service and governed BI capabilities. It enables users to access, analyze, and act on data, thereby delivering trusted data experiences. Looker's features extend to building data-powered applications, offering embedded analytics, and embedded data modeling. It supports organizational business intelligence, self-service BI, and the construction of workflows and applications. Additionally, Looker's generative AI feature and chat functionality for engaging with business data distinguish it from traditional BI tools.

    Airflow

    Airflow is an open-source workflow management platform designed primarily for scheduling and monitoring workflows. It is used to author, plan, and execute workflows, which can include data processing tasks. Airflow's capability is centered around workflow automation rather than direct data analytics or BI. The platform does not inherently provide BI functions such as data analysis, application building, or data chat capabilities that Looker offers.

    Sourcetable

    Sourcetable is a spreadsheet interface that integrates with various data sources for data analysis and collaboration. While it offers data analysis similar to Looker, it is primarily focused on providing a user-friendly spreadsheet environment for data collaboration. Unlike Looker, Sourcetable is not known for building data-powered applications or offering embedded analytics features. It does not have a generative AI feature and is less focused on enterprise-level BI solutions.

    Contrasts and Commonalities

  • BI and Analytics: While both Looker and Sourcetable are used for BI and analytics, Looker offers a more robust set of features including self-service BI, governed BI, and embedded analytics.
  • Workflow Automation: Airflow stands out for its workflow automation capabilities, which are not a primary function of Looker or Sourcetable.
  • Application Development: Looker allows for the development of data-powered applications, a feature not inherent to Airflow or Sourcetable.
  • AI and Chat Functionality: Looker's generative AI feature and data chat capabilities provide advanced interaction with data, which is not available in Airflow or Sourcetable.
  • Data Governance: Looker's governed BI feature implies a level of data governance that is not explicitly indicated by Airflow or Sourcetable.
  • User Interface: Sourcetable's spreadsheet interface is designed for ease of use and collaboration, contrasting with Looker's more comprehensive BI platform.
  • sourcetable

    Frequently Asked Questions About Sourcetable

    What is Sourcetable and who typically uses it?

    Sourcetable is a spreadsheet application that replaces workflows typically done in Excel, Google Sheets, and Business Intelligence tools. It is used by growth teams and business operations folks who need to centralize, analyze, and model data that updates over time.

    Does Sourcetable require coding skills?

    No, Sourcetable does not require any coding. Users can query data and build live models without needing to write code.

    How often does Sourcetable sync data from other applications?

    Sourcetable syncs data from over 100 applications and most databases every 15 minutes on the regular plan and every 5 minutes on the pro plan.

    How much does Sourcetable cost?

    Sourcetable costs $50 per month for the starter plan and $250 per month for the pro plan. Additional seats cost $20 per month per user.

    Does Sourcetable offer a free trial?

    Yes, all plans of Sourcetable have a 14-day free trial period.

    Google Looker

    Google Looker Cost Overview

    Google Looker's pricing is composed of two primary components: platform pricing and user pricing. Platform pricing is a fixed cost associated with running a Looker instance, which includes administration, integrations, and semantic modeling capabilities. User pricing varies and depends on licensing individual users for platform access.

    • Platform Pricing

      Platform pricing is mandatory for running a Looker instance and ensures platform functionality. This cost includes the essentials for platform administration, the ability to integrate with other systems, and tools for semantic modeling. Each Looker instance is linked to a billing account, which is charged for platform usage.

    • User Pricing

      User pricing is determined by the type of license and permissions assigned to each user. Charges for adding users to a Looker instance are billed to the instance's associated billing account. Looker offers three types of user licenses: Developer User, Standard User, and Viewer User, each incurring different costs based on permissions.

    • Platform Editions and Subscription Terms

      Looker provides three platform editions: Standard, Enterprise, and Embed. The cost of each edition varies according to user type and permissions. Looker offers annual subscriptions with one, two, or three-year term options, catering to various business needs and commitment preferences.

    tool icon

    Airflow Cost Overview

    Airflow is an open-source platform, eliminating the need for licensing fees. It is developed by the community and is tailored for crafting, scheduling, and monitoring workflows. The open-source nature ensures it is accessible without direct cost.

    • Operational Costs

      While Airflow itself is free, running it may incur costs. These can include expenses for servers, cloud services, or infrastructure required to host and operate Airflow instances. Expertise in Python is a prerequisite, which may involve training expenses.

    • Use Cases and Efficiency

      Airflow's ease of use can lead to reduced development time and cost savings. It is versatile, being applied in building ML models, transferring data, and managing infrastructure, potentially consolidating tools and resources.

    Google Looker

    User Reviews of Google Looker

    • Overall Sentiment

      Google Looker, a business intelligence (BI) and analytics platform, receives mixed feedback in user reviews.

    • Negative Reviews

      Some users rate Looker as the worst reporting tool available. Complaints highlight performance issues, with users finding it slow and buggy. Additionally, the interface is criticized for being unintuitive.

    • Comparisons with Competitors

      When compared to other BI tools, both free and paid, such as Data Studio and Tableau, Looker is often deemed inferior according to user reviews.

    tool icon

    User Reviews and Opinions on Airflow

    Despite its widespread usage, a notable number of users express dissatisfaction with Airflow. This could suggest shortcomings in features or usability that current users encounter. However, the extent of discontent might be influenced by the possibility of a biased sample in the author's review pool.

    • Competitive Landscape

      When considering alternative solutions, Airflow still maintains a strong presence in the market. Platforms like Astronomer and Dagster are not currently perceived as significant threats to Airflow's dominance, indicating that users continue to rely on Airflow despite any reported issues.

    Conclusion

    Both Google Looker and Airflow offer robust solutions for business intelligence, with Looker providing integrated data visualization and business analytics, while Airflow excels in workflow automation and data engineering tasks.

    While they serve different aspects of data handling, businesses often need a straightforward tool that offers real-time data syncing across services.

    Sourcetable addresses this need by offering a simplified business intelligence approach, allowing users to manage and analyze their data within a familiar spreadsheet interface.



    Simplify Your BI Tooling

    Sourcetable is the AI spreadsheet that lets you analyze your data in one place. Get unlimited access free for 14 days.


    Drop CSV