Qlikview vs Amazon QuickSight: A Comparative Analysis
Introduction
Choosing the right business intelligence tool is crucial for effective data analysis and reporting. Qlikview and Amazon Quicksight are two prominent players in the BI tool market, each offering unique features and benefits.
This comparison will dive into the specifics of Qlikview and Amazon Quicksight, examining their interfaces, ease of use, and data handling capabilities. By looking at the strengths and limitations of both, we aim to assist you in making an informed decision for your data analytics needs.
Additionally, we'll explore how Sourcetable provides a modernized, spreadsheet-like interface that syncs with your data, presenting an alternative to using Qlikview or Amazon Quicksight for business intelligence tasks like reporting and data analytics.
What is QlikView?
QlikView is a guided analytics solution designed for the rapid development and delivery of analytics applications and dashboards. It features an associative engine that facilitates the generation of new data views on the fly, enhancing the analytical experience.
-
QlikView is a guided analytics solution designed for the rapid development and delivery of analytics applications and dashboards. It features an associative engine that facilitates the generation of new data views on the fly, enhancing the analytical experience.
-
Key Features
- Associative engine for dynamic data view creation.
- In-memory data compression for efficient data exploration.
- Support for multiple concurrent users analyzing data in memory.
- Capability to connect directly to various data sources.
- Provides an associative experience across all data used in analysis.
- Allows flexible user exploration without predefined drill paths or dashboards.
What is Amazon QuickSight?
Amazon QuickSight is a fully managed business intelligence service that delivers insights and enables data analysis for organizations. It provides a secure, scalable, and easy-to-use platform for building visualizations, performing ad-hoc analysis, and quickly getting business insights from data.
-
Amazon QuickSight is a fully managed business intelligence service that delivers insights and enables data analysis for organizations. It provides a secure, scalable, and easy-to-use platform for building visualizations, performing ad-hoc analysis, and quickly getting business insights from data.
-
Key Features
- Connects to data in the cloud, allowing integration with various data sources.
- Includes SPICE, an in-memory engine for fast response times.
- Offers enterprise-grade security with extra security features.
- Provides user-management tools for simplified access management.
- Enables collaborative analytics with shared and personal folders.
- Supports creating and controlling features in dashboards for tailored analytics.
- Employs machine learning to make forecasts, identify outliers, and reveal trends.
- Translates data into narratives for easy comprehension.
- Facilitates embedding analytics and dashboards into applications.
- Offers multitenancy suitable for value-added resellers.
- Allows scripting of dashboard templates for efficiency.
- Supports larger data imports and more frequent data refreshes to maintain up-to-date analysis.
-
Benefits
- Available globally with built-in redundancy for high availability.
- Provides a low total cost of ownership (TCO) for economical scaling.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Key Features of QlikView
Associative Engine |
The associative engine is the cornerstone of QlikView's uniqueness, enabling complex data analysis. |
Intuitive Visual Discovery |
Intuitive visual discovery facilitates user interaction with data, fostering a better understanding of analytics. |
Qlik Cloud Analytics & Qlik Sense Integration |
Qlik Cloud Analytics and Qlik Sense enhance analytics with AI, transitioning users towards active data engagement. |
Deployment Options |
|
Amazon Quicksight Features
Browser Support |
Amazon Quicksight provides compatibility with multiple web browsers, ensuring accessibility for users across different platforms. Legacy support for Internet Explorer was maintained by AWS until July 31, 2022. |
Advantages of Qlikview for Business Intelligence
Self-Service BI Tool
Qlikview empowers users with self-service capabilities, facilitating quick and efficient data interaction without extensive IT dependency.
Dynamic Data Interaction
Its visual and dynamic dashboards enhance data interpretation and analysis, leading to accelerated decision-making processes.
Collaborative Decision-Making
Qlikview fosters teamwork, allowing multiple stakeholders to collaborate and make informed, data-driven decisions.
Simplicity and Implementation
The tool's ease of implementation and user-friendly interface ensure a smooth adoption curve across business levels.
Data Security and Speed
Qlikview ensures robust data security while providing high-speed data processing, both essential for reliable BI tasks.
In-Memory Technology
Its advanced in-memory technology supports efficient data handling and quick insights.
Data Compression and Visualization
Qlikview's data compression mechanisms reduce storage costs, while its superior data visualization capabilities allow for clear data presentation.
QIX Engine
The powerful QIX Engine underpinning Qlikview accelerates data retrieval and augments user experience.
Cost-Effectiveness
With its cost-effective pricing, Qlikview delivers a competitive edge in business intelligence without a hefty investment.
Disadvantages of Qlikview in Business Intelligence
Inefficiency in Real-Time Data Analysis
Qlikview may not be the most efficient tool for real-time data analysis, potentially limiting its effectiveness in scenarios that require immediate insights.
Technical Expertise Requirement
The need for technical expertise to develop applications in Qlikview can be a barrier to adoption, especially for organizations with limited IT resources.
Integration Challenges
Embedding Qlikview with other software systems may pose difficulties, possibly leading to suboptimal utilization within the business intelligence ecosystem.
Customer Support Concerns
Users may experience poor customer support, which could result in longer resolution times for issues, affecting productivity and user satisfaction.
Outdated Tools and Interfaces
The presence of old tools and interfaces in Qlikview may deter users looking for modern, intuitive user experiences.
Cost Implications for SMBs
Qlikview's pricing may be prohibitive for small to medium-sized businesses, making it a less viable option for these entities.
User Feedback and Ratings
Poor ratings in surveys may reflect user dissatisfaction and can influence prospective buyers when considering Qlikview for their business intelligence needs.
Frequently Asked Questions About Qlikview
How much memory does QlikView use when running a script compared to working in the layout?
QlikView uses 3-4 times as much memory when running a script as when working in the layout.
What is the data handling capacity of QlikView on a PC and on large servers?
QlikView can handle a few million rows of typical transaction data on a PC with 512MB of RAM, and up to one billion rows of transaction data on large servers.
Can QlikView join fields with different names?
Yes, QlikView can join fields with different names using an alias or AS statement.
How can QlikView be shared with others?
QlikView can be shared with others using QlikView Server or QlikView Publisher.
Can QlikView limit user access to a document?
Yes, QlikView can limit who can use a document using section access.
Use Cases for Qlikview
-
Improving efficiency, customer service, and sales
-
Simplifying analytics with a company-wide portal
-
Boosting operational success
-
Lowering costs and reducing effort to convert loan prospects
Advantages of Amazon QuickSight for Business Intelligence
Cost-Effectiveness and Speed
Amazon QuickSight stands out as a cost-effective and fast Business Intelligence (BI) tool. As part of AWS, it offers rapid data analysis, allowing businesses to make informed decisions quickly.
Interactivity and Accessibility
This BI tool is designed for high interactivity, enabling users to delve deep into analytics. Its accessibility across multiple devices ensures that users can gain insights on-the-go, enhancing productivity and decision-making processes.
Data Visualization and Self-Service Analysis
QuickSight's capability to visualize data and provide self-service analysis empowers users to comprehend complex datasets easily. Business owners can measure critical metrics independently, without relying on IT staff.
Scalability and Versatility
Amazon QuickSight's scalability is suited for businesses of all sizes, adapting to growing data needs. Its versatility across several business domains makes it a widely applicable tool for various reporting and analytics tasks.
Collaboration and Multi-User Environment
With support for tens of thousands of users simultaneously, QuickSight facilitates a collaborative environment while allowing users to work independently, streamlining BI tasks across the organization.
Data Source Integration
The ability to handle multiple data sources seamlessly within QuickSight ensures comprehensive data analytics, providing a unified view of business health.
Disadvantages of Amazon QuickSight for Business Intelligence
Limited Data Modeling Capabilities
Amazon QuickSight's inability to handle complex data modeling in dashboards constrains users from performing intricate data analysis, potentially leading to less insightful business intelligence outcomes.
Dataset Limitations
Users face unusual constraints with QuickSight when dealing with child datasets originating from datasets with Row-Level Security (RLSS) applied, as well as general challenges in dataset creation and loading, hampering efficient data management.
Refresh Flexibility Issues
Lack of flexible options for dataset refreshing through the user interface in QuickSight can cause delays and complications in updating reports with the most current data.
Advanced Functionality Restrictions
QuickSight's limitations in advanced dashboard functionalities may prevent users from executing comprehensive data analytics, affecting the depth of reporting and insights.
Stability Concerns
The presence of more bugs and oversights than expected in QuickSight could lead to reliability issues, potentially affecting critical business intelligence processes.
Environment Support Deficit
The absence of support for a Development, Quality Assurance, and Production (Dev/QA/Prod) environment in QuickSight undermines the ability to manage lifecycle stages for BI projects systematically.
Inefficient File Management
QuickSight's folders, not functioning as true folders, can lead to disorganized file management and difficulty in locating specific BI resources.
Version Control Challenges
Without straightforward version control capabilities, QuickSight users may struggle to track changes and maintain consistency across BI reports and datasets.
Frequently Asked Questions About Amazon Quicksight
What browsers does Amazon Quicksight support?
Amazon Quicksight supports Chrome, Firefox, Edge, and Safari.
Can I use Internet Explorer to access Amazon Quicksight?
No, AWS support for Internet Explorer ended on 07/31/2022.
Will Amazon Quicksight work on any browser?
No, it only works on Chrome, Firefox, Edge, and Safari.
Use Cases for Amazon Quicksight
-
Making reliable forecasts using machine learning capabilities
-
Identifying outliers and hidden trends in business data
-
Creating comprehensive dashboards that combine AWS data, third-party data, and more
-
Delivering insights across an organization with secure, scalable analytics
-
Connecting and visualizing data from multiple cloud-based sources for enhanced reporting
Sourcetable as a Superior Business Intelligence Tool
-
Unified Data Synchronization
Sourcetable offers a streamlined process for data synchronization, which contrasts with the separate cloud-based and on-premises solutions of Qlikview and the distinct offerings of Amazon Quicksight. This simplification can lead to more efficient data management and reduced complexity for users.
-
Intuitive Spreadsheet-Like Interface
The spreadsheet-like interface of Sourcetable is inherently familiar to many users, reducing the learning curve and increasing adoption rates compared to the more specialized interfaces of Qlikview's associative engine and Amazon Quicksight's analytics tools.
-
Enhanced Reporting Capabilities
Sourcetable's focus on simplifying reporting allows for quick generation of actionable insights, which may provide an advantage over Qlikview and Amazon Quicksight when it comes to producing and sharing business intelligence reports.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Comparison of QlikView and Amazon QuickSight
Deployment Options
Both QlikView and Amazon QuickSight offer flexible deployment options. QlikView is available for cloud-based and on-premises deployments, catering to various business needs. Similarly, Amazon QuickSight provides a cloud-based SaaS solution, making it accessible from anywhere without the need for on-premises infrastructure.
Data Visualization and Discovery
QlikView and Amazon QuickSight emphasize intuitive visual discovery of data. QlikView's associative engine enables users to explore connections within data visually. Amazon QuickSight also focuses on easy-to-use visualizations, catering to users who need to create and share insights quickly.
Scalability and Collaboration
Both platforms scale to accommodate a large number of users and datasets, facilitating collaboration across organizations. They enable real-time data exploration and allow teams to work together effectively on data analysis tasks.
Artificial Intelligence and Business Intelligence
QlikView and Amazon QuickSight integrate AI to enhance data analysis. QlikView uses AI-powered insights to augment human intuition, while Amazon QuickSight leverages machine learning to provide predictive analytics and anomaly detection, helping users to uncover hidden insights within their data.
Qlikview vs Amazon Quicksight
Analytics Solution Origin
QlikView was the first analytics solution launched by Qlik, establishing a legacy in data analytics. In contrast, Amazon QuickSight is a later entrant by Amazon Web Services, building on the cloud provider's expansive ecosystem.
Data Processing Engine
QlikView utilizes an associative engine for data processing which revolutionized organizational data use. Amazon QuickSight does not use an associative engine, relying instead on SPICE (Super-fast, Parallel, In-memory Calculation Engine).
Data Discovery and Visualization
QlikView offers intuitive visual discovery capabilities, while Amazon QuickSight provides visualization tools and automatic visual generation but does not emphasize an associative model for data exploration.
Deployment Options
Artificial Intelligence and Collaboration
Business Intelligence Accessibility
QlikView puts business intelligence in the hands of more people through its associative engine, whereas Amazon QuickSight aims to democratize BI with pay-per-session pricing and user-friendly interfaces.
Comparison of QlikView, Amazon QuickSight, and Sourcetable
QlikView vs. Amazon QuickSight
QlikView: QlikView was the first analytics solution from Qlik, utilizing an associative engine for data analysis which revolutionized the business intelligence sector. It supports both cloud-based SaaS and on-premises deployments, offering flexibility in data storage and analysis. QlikView emphasizes intuitive visual discovery and real-time collaboration, enhanced by AI-powered insights.
Amazon QuickSight: Amazon QuickSight is a cloud-native BI service provided by Amazon Web Services (AWS). It does not offer an on-premises solution. QuickSight focuses on scalability and serverless operations, integrating seamlessly with other AWS services. It employs machine learning for advanced analytics but does not utilize an associative engine like QlikView.
QlikView vs. Sourcetable
QlikView: Geared towards more comprehensive business intelligence needs, QlikView provides a robust set of features for visual discovery and analytics. Its unique associative engine allows complex data relationship analysis and it caters to a variety of deployment needs including cloud and on-premises.
Sourcetable: Sourcetable is typically known as a user-friendly spreadsheet interface that blends data from multiple sources for simplified reporting and analysis. While it offers visual discovery tools, it may not have the same depth of analytical capabilities or the associative engine that QlikView possesses.
Amazon QuickSight vs. Sourcetable
Amazon QuickSight: As a fully managed service, QuickSight provides enterprise-level analytics and integrates with AWS's ecosystem, appealing to users already invested in AWS. It focuses on ease of use and quick insights, with a pay-per-session pricing model that can be cost-effective for sporadic use.
Sourcetable: Sourcetable aims to simplify data manipulation and reporting, offering a more accessible approach for users who may not require the full breadth of enterprise analytics. It's suitable for merging data from various sources and creating reports without the need for complex infrastructure.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Frequently Asked Questions About Sourcetable
What is Sourcetable and who typically uses it?
Sourcetable is a spreadsheet that allows users to access data from most 3rd party applications, query data, and build live models. It is typically used by growth teams and business operations teams.
How does Sourcetable replace traditional tools like Excel and Google Sheets?
Sourcetable replaces workflows that are typically done in Excel, Google Sheets, and Business Intelligence tools by allowing users to centralize, analyze, and model data that updates over time without requiring any coding.
How much does Sourcetable cost and is there a trial period?
Sourcetable costs $50 per month for the starter plan and $250 per month for the pro plan. All plans come with a 14-day free trial period.
How often does Sourcetable update data from integrations?
Data integrations update every 15 minutes on the regular plan and every 5 minutes on the pro plan.
Do I need to know how to code to use Sourcetable?
No, Sourcetable does not require any coding to use.
Qlikview Pricing Structure
-
Standard Plan
The Qlikview standard plan is designed for a minimum of 20 full users. It provides essential features including 25 GB/year of data analysis capacity, the ability to connect and combine hundreds of data sources, interactive data visualizations, dashboards, augmented analytics with AI, team collaboration options, and 24x7 customer support.
-
Premium Plan
The premium plan builds upon the standard plan by doubling the data analysis capacity to 50 GB/year. Additional premium features include automated report compilation and delivery, enhanced predictive analytics with automated machine learning, no-code automation builder triggers, and advanced data governance. Subscribers of this plan also receive a personalized customer success plan.
-
Enterprise Plan
For large-scale needs, the enterprise plan offers 500 GB/year of data analysis capacity. This plan encompasses all the benefits of the premium plan, addressing the requirements of enterprise-level data management and analytics with expansive data governance capabilities.
-
Additional Information
All plans alert users as they approach their capacity limit, ensuring efficient data management and preventing unexpected disruptions in service.
Amazon Quicksight Costs
-
Paginated Reports
Quicksight charges a flat rate of $500 per month for paginated reports.
-
Session Pricing
Users are billed $0.30 per session, with a maximum charge of $5 per month.
-
Alerts Pricing
- $0.50 per 1000 metrics evaluated for alerts.
- $0.0005 for each additional metric evaluated for alerts.
User Reviews of QlikView
QlikView has garnered an overall rating of 4.3 out of 5. Users appreciate its functionality, giving it a 4.5 rating in this area. However, in terms of ease-of-use and customer support, it has received a 4-rating. The value for money aspect also stands at 4, indicating satisfactory cost efficiency.
-
QlikView has garnered an overall rating of 4.3 out of 5. Users appreciate its functionality, giving it a 4.5 rating in this area. However, in terms of ease-of-use and customer support, it has received a 4-rating. The value for money aspect also stands at 4, indicating satisfactory cost efficiency.
-
Functionality and Usability
Users find QlikView to be a versatile tool for data visualization, capable of combining data sources to generate complex reports. The ease of implementation and intuitive interface are highlighted, along with its in-memory processing that facilitates fast data processing. Despite its speed, QlikView has been noted to slow down with heavy data volumes and experiences delays in real-time data synchronization.
-
Integration and Customization
Although QlikView integrates data from various sources and is easy to use, users find its UI clunky and less user-friendly with certain data sources like BW and Big Data. Customization is possible through VBA or other programming languages, but it lacks R integration, making it less versatile in some analytical scenarios.
-
Support and Community
With a wide user group and support forum over the internet, QlikView provides ample support, making it particularly useful for students writing their thesis. Despite this, QlikView does not allow exporting a list of all currently licensed users, which could be a drawback for some organizations.
-
Comparisons and Limitations
When compared to other BI tools, users have noted that QlikView is not as good as Qlik Sense, Tableau, or PowerBI, particularly in terms of visualization capabilities and detailed reporting. Additionally, there is no option for write-back to the database. Its pricing is also considered expensive relative to its shortcomings.
-
Value and Performance
Users assert that QlikView provides a ton of value and is especially beneficial in creating sales and inventory dashboards. Its in-memory processing and scheduled batch jobs for ETL contribute to its performance. Despite its price, many users find QlikView to be a powerful BI tool that is helpful in automating report distribution and creation.
Amazon Quicksight User Reviews
Amazon Quicksight reviews often highlight the tool’s capacity to handle large datasets, with users noting the ability to work with datasets up to 1 TB. However, users frequently point out that Quicksight does not offer a robust data model akin to that of PowerBI, which can be a limitation for those used to structured data modeling techniques.
-
Amazon Quicksight reviews often highlight the tool’s capacity to handle large datasets, with users noting the ability to work with datasets up to 1 TB. However, users frequently point out that Quicksight does not offer a robust data model akin to that of PowerBI, which can be a limitation for those used to structured data modeling techniques.
-
Functional Limitations
- There are constraints when attempting to create child SPICE datasets from those already utilizing SPICE with Row-Level Security (RLSS), as reported by users.
- Users have cited frustrations with the limitations on refreshing datasets, which can impact data timeliness and relevance.
- The platform's limitations on establishing a Dev/QA/Prod environment have been mentioned, indicating challenges in managing development workflows and version control.
- Organizing dashboards effectively is hampered by the limitations on using folders, as experienced by users, which can affect usability at scale.
Note: The reviews and ratings referenced in this summary are based on user feedback from various forums and tech review sites. They represent common trends and points of critique among users of Amazon Quicksight.
Conclusion
In summary, while Qlikview offers robust data modeling capabilities, Amazon Quicksight stands out for its integration with AWS services and pay-per-session pricing model.
For those seeking a more streamlined solution, Sourcetable provides real-time data synchronization across services within a user-friendly spreadsheet interface.
This simplification can benefit organizations looking to implement business intelligence without the complexity often associated with traditional tools.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Simplify Your BI Tooling
Sourcetable is the AI spreadsheet that lets you analyze your data in one place. Get unlimited access free for 14 days.