Google Looker
tool icon

Google Looker vs Pentaho: A Comparative Analysis

Jump to

    Introduction

    In the realm of business intelligence and data analytics, Google Looker and Pentaho are two powerful tools that offer distinct features and functionalities. This comparative analysis aims to dissect their capabilities, user interfaces, and integration options to assist organizations in making an informed decision.

    While both platforms have their merits, it's crucial to consider modern alternatives that can cater to the evolving needs of businesses. We'll also explore how Sourcetable provides a modernized, spreadsheet-like interface that syncs with your data, positioning itself as a viable alternative to Google Looker or Pentaho for business intelligence tasks like reporting and data analytics.

    Google Looker

    What is Google Looker?

    Google Looker is a business intelligence platform that operates in the cloud, enabling users to access and manage data with ease. As a product of Google Cloud, it provides a seamless experience for analyzing and acting on business data.

    • Core Features

    • Access, analyze, and act on data for informed business decisions.
    • Deliver tailored data experiences across an organization.
    • Interact with business data through chat.
    • Utilize generative AI to create data-driven applications.
    • Develop custom applications with consistent and reliable metrics.
    • Integrate Looker modeling with pre-existing BI tools, maintaining a governed BI environment.

    • Accessibility and Governance

      Available on the cloud, Google Looker offers a self-service platform that maintains governance over business intelligence processes, ensuring that data handling is both flexible and secure.

    tool icon

    What is Pentaho?

    Pentaho is a comprehensive data management platform that streamlines and optimizes the handling of large datasets. It encompasses a suite of tools tailored for efficient data processing, including optimization, cataloging, integration, and analytical operations.

    • Key Products

    • Data Optimizer
    • Data Catalog
    • Data Integration
    • Business Analytics

      • Utilizing advanced technologies such as AI and ML, Pentaho enhances data management capabilities. This allows businesses to extract valuable insights, fostering informed decision-making and promoting innovation for improved outcomes.

    Google Looker

    Google Looker Features

    Business Intelligence Capabilities

    Looker serves as a BI tool offering enterprise-class business intelligence and proactive insights.

    Real-Time Data View

    Looker provides a fresh, consistent, and governed real-time view of data.

    Data Access and Integration

    Looker integrates with multiple clouds and services, offering access to data across platforms and integration with Looker Studio and the Google Cloud console.

    LookML for Data Modeling

    Looker utilizes LookML, a SQL-based modeling language, to allow analysts to centrally manage business rules and definitions.

    Version Control and Governance

    Looker employs Git version-controlled data modeling to ensure governed data management.

    Report and Dashboard Creation

    The tool simplifies the process of creating reports and dashboards for data analysis.

    Connectivity and Analysis

    Users can connect to Looker's semantic model to analyze and visualize data through Looker Studio.

    Cloud Infrastructure and Services

    As a core product of Google Cloud, Looker is built on Google Cloud infrastructure and is available as a Google Cloud service.

    Prebuilt Integrations and APIs

    Looker offers prebuilt integrations and robust APIs for extended functionality and connectivity.

    tool icon

    Pentaho Features Overview

    Codeless Data Management

    Pentaho is a codeless platform designed for the seamless preparation, building, deployment, and analysis of enterprise data.

    Deployment Flexibility

    Pentaho provides deployment options both on-premises and in the cloud. Its Enterprise Edition (EE) Cloud is compatible with major cloud providers including AWS, Google Cloud, and Azure.

    Data Integration & Analytics

    The software comes equipped with a comprehensive set of tools for data integration and analytics, facilitating a wide range of data-processing tasks.

    Trial Access

    Prospective users can evaluate Pentaho's capabilities with a free 30-day trial.

    Community Edition

    The open-source Pentaho Community Edition includes core platform engines and allows for experimentation with a subset of the full feature set, albeit with limited ETL capabilities.

    Google Looker

    Advantages of Google Looker for Business Intelligence

    Data Exploration and Visualization

    Looker Studio Pro enables in-depth data exploration and the creation of visualizations, facilitating the extraction of actionable insights from business data.

    Enterprise Capabilities

    This tool is tailored for medium to large enterprises, providing robust capabilities that support complex data analytics needs within large-scale environments.

    Collaboration and Sharing

    With features designed for team collaboration, Looker Studio Pro enhances productivity by allowing team members to manage content and share dashboards effectively.

    Enterprise Support

    Users have access to enterprise-level support, ensuring that any issues can be addressed promptly, minimizing downtime and maintaining business continuity.

    Google Looker

    Disadvantages of Using Google Looker for Business Intelligence

    Connectivity and Integration Challenges

    Google Looker users have reported difficulties with connectivity, especially when migrating data from AWS to BigQuery, which can be a painful process. This can pose a significant obstacle for businesses relying on seamless integration for data analytics.

    Complex Sharing Mechanism

    The platform's sharing mechanism is complicated, which can hinder collaboration and slow down decision-making processes within an organization.

    Usability Issues

    Looker is not very intuitive and has been described as laggy, particularly when handling many graphs on a single page. This can impede user adoption and reduce efficiency in data analysis tasks.

    Learning Curve and Onboarding Costs

    There is a consensus among users about the steep learning curve associated with Google Looker, which can lead to prolonged onboarding times and increased costs.

    Performance and Speed

    Performance issues are a common concern, with users experiencing slow load times on the website, which can be exacerbated by the presence of multiple graphs.

    Limited Accessibility to Resources

    Training materials and documentation for Google Looker are not readily accessible, making it challenging for users to find the help they need to overcome the platform's steep learning curve.

    Restrictive Access

    The security team's heavy restrictions on access can limit users' ability to fully leverage Looker's capabilities, further complicating the data analytics process.

    Google Looker

    Frequently Asked Questions About Google Looker

    When is Looker Support available for English speakers?

    Looker Support is available 24/7 in English.

    How do I ensure my Looker instance is eligible for support?

    Ensure your instance is running an officially supported Looker version. Instances hosted by Looker automatically update to supported releases, while customer-hosted instances must be manually updated to a supported version.

    What do I need to do to receive support for my Looker (original) instance?

    For Looker (original) instances, you need to fill in the Google Cloud Project number on the Admin General Settings page to be eligible for Looker Support.

    Who is eligible to receive Looker Support?

    Looker Support is available to users with the Tech Support Editor IAM role and to administrators and developers on instances using Legacy Support.

    What are the support hours for Japanese language support?

    Japanese language support is available from 9:00 AM JST to 5:00 PM JST, Monday to Friday, and from 5:00 PM JST to 9:00 AM JST, Monday to Saturday, including weekends and holidays.

    Use Cases for Google Looker

    • Google Looker

      Reducing client report time

    • Google Looker

      Modernizing business intelligence

    • Google Looker

      Embedding analytics in quote-to-revenue platforms

    tool icon

    Advantages of Pentaho for Business Intelligence

    Comprehensive Toolset

    Pentaho offers a wide array of tools for diverse BI tasks, including a mature data integration module, robust reporting, and effective dashboard development capabilities. Its capacity to handle large and complex data sets makes it suitable for various organizational sizes and needs.

    Customization and Flexibility

    Highly customizable and flexible, Pentaho caters to specific business requirements, allowing for tailored BI solutions. It supports scheduled ETL processes and complex analytic use cases, proving advantageous for businesses seeking to adapt and evolve their BI strategies.

    User-Friendly Interface

    With an easy-to-learn interface, Pentaho simplifies the creation of jobs and transformations. Interactive analysis reports enhance user engagement without requiring extensive training, streamlining the adoption process within organizations.

    Data Handling Capabilities

    The platform's data integration and ingestion modules are designed to efficiently process XML and JSON-based data. Pentaho's reliability in managing data ensures stable and robust ETL operations, essential for maintaining data integrity and accuracy.

    Integration and Future-Readiness

    Integrating with other systems is straightforward with Pentaho, promoting interoperability. Being future-friendly, the platform positions businesses to leverage emerging technologies, including machine learning, for advanced data analytics.

    Visualization and Reporting

  • Pentaho's reporting tools are recognized for their effectiveness, making it a valuable asset for generating insightful reports.
  • Visualizations are particularly beneficial for sales and marketing presentations, aiding in data-driven decision-making.
    • tool icon

    Disadvantages of Using Pentaho for Business Intelligence

    Limited Visualization and Scalability

    Pentaho's data visualization capabilities are not as robust as some users may require. Additionally, its Mondrian-based ROLAP feature struggles to scale effectively with a growing number of subscribers and expanding time periods, which can be a significant drawback for dynamic and large-scale BI operations.

    Insufficient WEKA Support and Usage

    Users of Pentaho's WEKA machine learning platform face a lack of support and guidance, which can hinder the effective application of machine learning techniques in BI. Furthermore, WEKA is not commonly utilized in production environments, suggesting limitations in its practicality for real-world data analytics.

    ETL and Scheduling Challenges

    The ETL tool provided by Pentaho does not offer clear error codes, making troubleshooting a challenging task. Users also experience difficulties when attempting to schedule ETL packages using the Windows Task Scheduler. Moreover, database connections are prone to time out, which can disrupt continuous data processing.

    Outdated Design Tools and Learning Curve

    Pentaho's options for creating diagrams and charts are limited to types of graphs and layouts that are considered outdated. The tools for generating new report templates also require enhancement. These shortcomings, combined with a notable learning curve, can lead to a less efficient BI process and a steeper path to proficiency for new users.

    Reputation and Performance

    Compared to other BI tools on the market, Pentaho does not have the same level of reputation, which might affect the trust potential users have in its capabilities. Additionally, Pentaho is hampered by performance issues, particularly with many steps in the process, and has certain data limitations that could impede comprehensive analytics.

    tool icon

    Frequently Asked Questions About Pentaho

    What is Pentaho primarily used for?

    Pentaho is a software used for data-driven tasks.

    Is Pentaho suitable for mission-critical projects?

    Yes, Pentaho is designed for mission-critical purposes.

    Can Pentaho be applied to COVID-19 related projects?

    Yes, Pentaho can be used for COVID-19 related work.

    Use Cases for Pentaho

    • tool icon

      Building a data warehouse

    • tool icon

      Analyzing sales data

    • tool icon

      Analyzing customer data

    • tool icon

      Creating dashboards and reports

    sourcetable

    Comparing Sourcetable with Google Looker and Pentaho for Business Intelligence

    • Streamlined Reporting and Analytics

      Sourcetable stands out by enabling simplified reporting and data analytics. Unlike Google Looker and Pentaho, Sourcetable integrates data from various services into an intuitive spreadsheet interface, streamlining the user experience.

    • Unified Data Synchronization

      With Sourcetable, the synchronization of data across multiple platforms is centralized. This contrasts with Google Looker and Pentaho, which may not offer as straightforward a method for syncing disparate data sources.

    • Accessibility and Ease of Use

      The spreadsheet-like interface of Sourcetable provides an accessible user experience, benefiting users who prefer a familiar environment for data interaction. This user-friendly approach can be more appealing than the interfaces of Google Looker or Pentaho.

    • Cost-Effectiveness

      For organizations seeking a cost-effective solution, Sourcetable may offer a more attractive price point compared to the more comprehensive but potentially more costly platforms like Google Looker and Pentaho.

    Google Looker
    vs
    tool icon

    Comparing Google Looker and Pentaho

    Business Intelligence Capabilities

    Both Google Looker and Pentaho serve as business intelligence platforms. They enable organizations to analyze and visualize data for better decision-making processes.

    Data Accessibility and Analysis

    Google Looker and Pentaho allow users to access and analyze data, delivering insights that can be acted upon to drive business strategies.

    Self-Service and Governed BI

    Both platforms offer self-service and governed business intelligence, catering to a range of user expertise and maintaining data governance.

    Embedded Analytics

    Google Looker and Pentaho can be utilized for embedded analytics, integrating data insights directly into applications for seamless user experiences.

    Data-Driven Applications

    Both platforms have capabilities to build data-powered applications, enabling users to create interactive and data-centric applications for various business needs.

    Google Looker
    vs
    tool icon

    Google Looker vs. Pentaho

    Business Intelligence Platform

    Google Looker is a business intelligence platform that facilitates self-service and governed BI, whereas Pentaho is also a BI tool but with a focus on data integration and analytics.

    Data-Powered Applications

    Looker enables users to build data-powered applications directly within the platform, which is not a primary feature of Pentaho.

    Generative AI

    Google Looker offers a generative AI feature, a capability not typically associated with Pentaho.

    Data Accessibility

    Both platforms allow data access and analysis, but Looker emphasizes the ability to act on data through its integrated applications and workflows.

    Data Experiences

    Google Looker is designed to deliver trusted data experiences, including embedded analytics and data modeling, which may extend beyond Pentaho's core functionalities.

    Embedded Analytics

    Looker specializes in embedded analytics applications and data modeling, which contrasts with Pentaho's broader focus on data integration.

    Self-Service and Organizational BI

    Looker supports both self-service and organizational business intelligence, while Pentaho also offers these capabilities but with a strong emphasis on ETL (Extract, Transform, Load) processes.

    Interaction with Business Data

    Looker provides the unique feature of chatting with business data, enhancing user interaction, which is not a known feature of Pentaho.

    sourcetable

    Comparison of Google Looker, Pentaho, and Sourcetable

    Business Intelligence Capabilities

    Google Looker and Pentaho both serve as business intelligence platforms. Looker offers self-service and governed BI, enabling both flexibility for users and control for organizations. It also supports organizational business intelligence and self-service business intelligence. In contrast, Pentaho is known for its end-to-end BI capabilities, which include data integration, OLAP services, and reporting. Sourcetable, on the other hand, focuses on a spreadsheet interface to deliver its BI solutions, which may limit more advanced BI requirements.

    Data Applications and Analytics

    Looker allows users to build data-powered applications and can be used to build workflows and applications, while Pentaho is less focused on application development. Sourcetable, with its spreadsheet-centric approach, offers a more familiar environment for data analytics but may not be as robust for building applications as Looker.

    Embedded Analytics

    Both Looker and Pentaho offer strong support for embedded analytics. Looker provides embedded analytics applications and data modeling, catering to developers who want to integrate analytics into their applications. Pentaho also includes embedded analytics but with a broader set of tools for data integration. Sourcetable, while not explicitly known for embedded analytics, could technically be used to create and share analytical insights due to its spreadsheet nature.

    Generative AI and Chat

    Google Looker differentiates itself with a generative AI feature, which is not a noted feature of Pentaho or Sourcetable. Additionally, Looker provides the capability to chat with business data, adding a conversational layer to data interaction, not commonly found in traditional BI tools like Pentaho or the spreadsheet simplicity of Sourcetable.

    Data Accessibility and Governance

    Looker can be used to access, analyze, and act on data, and it is designed to deliver trusted data experiences that ensure data governance. Pentaho also prioritizes data governance but through a different set of tools and services that include data integration and cleansing. Sourcetable, while it allows data access and analysis, may not have the same level of governance features as Looker or Pentaho.

    sourcetable

    Frequently Asked Questions About Sourcetable

    What is Sourcetable and who typically uses it?

    Sourcetable is a spreadsheet application that allows users to access data from most 3rd party applications, query data, and build live models. It is typically used by growth teams and business operations teams.

    How does Sourcetable update data and what plans are available?

    Sourcetable syncs data from over 100 applications and most databases, with updates every 15 minutes on the regular plan and every 5 minutes on the pro plan. Sourcetable offers a starter plan for $50 / month and a pro plan for $250 / month.

    Do I need to know how to code to use Sourcetable?

    No, Sourcetable does not require any coding to use. Users can start creating reports within minutes and build live models that automatically update.

    What kind of trial does Sourcetable offer?

    All plans of Sourcetable come with a 14-day free trial. The trial includes 5 seats and additional seats can be purchased for $20 / month per seat.

    What workflows does Sourcetable replace?

    Sourcetable replaces workflows that are typically done in Excel, Google Sheets, and Business Intelligence tools, making it great for users who need to centralize, analyze, and model data that updates over time.

    Google Looker

    Google Looker Pricing Structure

    • Platform Pricing

      Looker's platform pricing is a fixed cost for running a Looker instance. It encompasses platform administration, integrations, and semantic modeling capabilities.

    • User Pricing

      User pricing is variable, based on licensing individual users on the Looker platform. The cost differs according to the type of user and their permissions.

    • Billing and Account Management

      Each Looker instance is associated with a billing account, with charges for new instances or additional users billed to this account.

    • Platform Editions and Subscription Terms

    • Looker offers three platform editions: Standard, Enterprise, and Embed.
    • The cost of these editions varies with user type and permissions.
    • Annual subscriptions are available with one, two, or three-year terms.

    • License Types

    • Developer User License
    • Standard User License
    • Viewer User License
    tool icon

    Pentaho Cost

    Pentaho is an open-source platform, which allows for no-cost access to its services. Users can benefit from Pentaho's features without a financial barrier.

    • Free Trial Availability

      Prospective users can explore Pentaho's capabilities through a free trial offered by the vendor. This opportunity enables evaluation without initial investment.

    • Cost Transparency

      The specific cost details for Pentaho are not disclosed by the vendor. This encourages direct inquiry for enterprise or commercial use.

    Google Looker

    User Reviews of Google Looker

    • General Feedback

      Google Looker is recognized as a business intelligence (BI) and analytics platform.

    • Negative Reviews

      Some users have expressed dissatisfaction with Looker, labeling it as the worst reporting tool available. Complaints center around its performance, with users finding it to be slow and buggy. Additionally, the platform is criticized for its lack of intuitiveness.

    • Comparative Feedback

      In comparison to other BI tools, users have shown a preference for free and paid alternatives such as Data Studio and Tableau, suggesting these are superior to Looker in functionality and user experience.

    tool icon

    User Reviews and Ratings of Pentaho

    • General Overview

      Pentaho is an open-source business intelligence suite that has garnered attention for its wide range of tools and features. It is praised for its flexibility and ease of learning. Pentaho's Data Integration module, in particular, is recognized for its accessibility and the ability to preview data in a pivot view format.

    • Strengths in ETL and Data Integration

      Users find Pentaho to be an effective solution for ETL processes, data ingestion, and preparing data for reporting. The Data Integration tool, also known as Pentaho Kettle, stands out as the best tool in the suite, offering capabilities to extract data from various sources, transform it, and load it into the target systems. It is valued for its graphical user interface and its efficiency in handling errors, logging, and performance, despite some performance issues with specific steps like JSON input.

    • Customization and Learning Curve

      The platform is highly customizable, which makes it appealing to organizations across industries. However, some users note a steep learning curve, especially with the visualization tools which are considered difficult to use.

    • Performance and Support

      While Pentaho is generally considered to be a good choice for open-source shops, some users report that it can be slow when reading JSON files and that the user interface needs improvement. Support is also mentioned as not being great, though the community around Pentaho is described as good.

    • Use Cases and Suitability

    • Pentaho is mainly used by IT teams for various purposes including data science, data mining, and machine learning.
    • It is capable of managing data in multiple environments and integrates well with big data.
    • Its flexibility makes it suitable for industries like healthcare, finance, and human resources.

    • Limitations

      Despite its strengths, Pentaho is not always considered the best tool for reporting when compared to others, and its visualization tools have a steep learning curve, making them less accessible to some users.

    • Summary

      Overall, Pentaho is described as agile, safe, powerful, and flexible. It is recommended for organizations dealing with information and databases, offering functionalities like embedding analytic content, bursting reports by email, and scheduling tasks.

    Conclusion

    Google Looker and Pentaho are both robust business intelligence tools that cater to different needs and preferences. Looker offers deep integration with other Google services, while Pentaho boasts a wide range of open-source capabilities.

    However, both can present a steep learning curve and may require significant setup time. This complexity can be a barrier for organizations seeking a more straightforward solution.

    Sourcetable offers an alternative by providing a simplified business intelligence experience. It syncs data in real-time across various services into an easy-to-use spreadsheet interface, reducing the time and expertise required to gain insights.

    Recommended Reading



    Simplify Your BI Tooling

    Sourcetable is the AI spreadsheet that lets you analyze your data in one place. Get unlimited access free for 14 days.


    Try out Sourcetable
    Drop CSV