Metabase vs Google Looker: An In-Depth Comparison
Introduction
Choosing the right business intelligence (BI) tool is crucial for effective data analysis and informed decision-making. Metabase and Google Looker are prominent players in the BI field, each offering unique features and capabilities.
While Metabase is known for its user-friendly interface and simplicity, Google Looker stands out with its powerful data modeling and advanced analytics. However, organizations often seek intuitive solutions that combine ease-of-use with robust functionality.
This comparison will delve into the specifics of Metabase and Google Looker, evaluating their strengths and weaknesses in the BI landscape. We'll also explore how Sourcetable offers a modernized, spreadsheet-like interface that syncs with your data as an alternative for business intelligence tasks like reporting and data analytics.
What is Metabase?
Metabase is an open-source analytics tool designed with a user-friendly UX, making data analysis accessible to a broad user base. It facilitates direct queries to over 20 types of data sources without the need for extracts.
-
Metabase is an open-source analytics tool designed with a user-friendly UX, making data analysis accessible to a broad user base. It facilitates direct queries to over 20 types of data sources without the need for extracts.
-
Key Features
- User-friendly UX
- Connection to multiple data sources
- Query execution without extracts
- Free open-source and Pro pay-as-you-go plans
- Hosted plan options
- Single sign-on capabilities
- Advanced permissions and auditing
- Embedded analytics
- GDPR compliance
- Docker deployment
-
Compliance and Security
Metabase ensures GDPR compliance and provides robust security features like single sign-on, permissions, and auditing to safeguard data integrity.
-
Deployment and Usage
With a diverse range of deployment options, including a docker deployment, Metabase caters to various business needs. Its adoption by over 50,000 companies underscores its reliability and effectiveness.
What is Google Looker?
Google Looker is a business intelligence platform that is part of the Google Cloud suite. It provides tools for accessing, analyzing, and acting on data. Users can engage in data-driven decision-making by utilizing Looker's capabilities to deliver comprehensive data experiences.
-
Google Looker is a business intelligence platform that is part of the Google Cloud suite. It provides tools for accessing, analyzing, and acting on data. Users can engage in data-driven decision-making by utilizing Looker's capabilities to deliver comprehensive data experiences.
-
Core Features
- Delivers a platform for users to analyze and visualize their data.
- Facilitates the building of data-powered applications using generative AI.
- Enables the integration of Looker with existing BI environments through Looker modeling.
- Allows the creation of custom applications with reliable metrics.
- Offers a self-service and governed environment, ensuring data governance and user autonomy.
- Operates entirely in the cloud, providing scalable and flexible data management solutions.
-
Interactive Data Features
- Provides a feature for users to chat with their business data.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Metabase Key Features
Scalability and Self-Service Analytics |
Metabase provides robust features for organizations to scale and deliver self-service internal or embedded analytics. These capabilities are enhanced for those on paid plans. |
Authentication Options |
Organizations on paid plans have access to advanced authentication options such as SAML and JWT. Google Sign-In allows for multiple domain authentication. |
Granular Permissions |
Paid plans offer comprehensive permissions options including data sandboxing for row and column-level control, and permissions for blocks, SQL snippets, applications, downloads, impersonation, database, and table metadata management. |
Management Tools |
Group managers can effectively handle people and group permissions, streamlining user management within the organization. |
Embedding and Customization |
|
Dashboard Subscriptions and Alerts |
|
Moderation and Caching |
Content moderation tools are provided, along with advanced caching controls, which include settings for individual questions. |
Data Portability |
There is the option to export Metabase application data, which is useful for setting up new instances. |
Key Features of Google Looker
Business Intelligence Capabilities |
Looker is a powerful BI tool that delivers enterprise-class intelligence, simplifying the creation of reports and dashboards. |
Real-Time Data View |
It provides users with a fresh, consistent, and governed real-time view of data, ensuring data accuracy and reliability. |
Data Access and Integration |
With Looker, data can be accessed from multiple clouds, and it integrates seamlessly with Looker Studio for enhanced data visualization. |
LookML for Data Management |
Looker utilizes LookML, a SQL-based modeling language, to allow analysts to centrally define and manage business rules and definitions. |
Version Control and Collaboration |
The Git version-controlled data model in LookML facilitates collaboration and consistent data management among users. |
Google Cloud Integration |
As a core product of Google Cloud, Looker is available as a Google Cloud service and is integrated within the Google Cloud console, streamlining the user experience. |
Extensibility and APIs |
Robust APIs and prebuilt integrations enhance Looker's extensibility, making it adaptable to various business needs. |
Benefits of Metabase Pro for Business Intelligence
Advanced Access Control
Metabase Pro enhances data governance with advanced permissions, including row-level and column-level permissions. This granular control ensures secure and relevant data access for users.
Customizable Embedded Analytics
Embedding capabilities within Metabase Pro allow for the integration of charts, dashboards, or the entire platform into business applications, promoting data-driven decision-making.
Branding and Personalization
White-labeling options and customizable aesthetics enable businesses to tailor the look and feel of Metabase Pro to align with their brand identity.
Dedicated Support Services
The world-class success team of Metabase Pro offers technical support, onboarding, and offboarding assistance, facilitating smooth BI operations.
Enhanced Analytics and Alerts
With usage analytics, subscriptions, and alerts, Metabase Pro empowers businesses to stay informed and proactive regarding their data insights.
Performance Optimization
Features such as caching for slow and unused content help in optimizing the performance of BI tasks by reducing load times.
Efficient Configuration Management
Exporting configurations and content as YAML files, synchronization across environments, and template creation from settings files streamline management and scaling of BI processes.
Role-Based Data Access
Role-based permissions on databases with connection impersonation further enhance secure data handling and integrity within Metabase Pro.
Disadvantages of Metabase for Business Intelligence
Complex Queries and Data Linking Challenges
Metabase presents difficulties in linking data which complicates asking complex queries. This limitation can impede in-depth data analysis.
Performance Issues
Performance degradation is notable when multiple team members access Metabase simultaneously, leading to slow response times. The software also struggles with large data loads, resulting in significant delay and latency.
Dashboard Functionality and Customization
Users find it challenging to create dashboards and customize charts in Metabase, limiting the ability to tailor reports to specific business needs.
Data Governance and Versioning
With a limited scope of data governance and lack of support for code versioning, Metabase falls short in maintaining data integrity over time.
System Updates and Compatibility
Metabase is difficult to update, and it does not support Azure SSO on its free edition, posing challenges in maintaining system security and compatibility.
Frequently Asked Questions About Metabase
How can I filter data by date in Metabase?
You can use the trend widget in Metabase to filter data by date.
I'm getting a 550 5.7.60 SMTP error in Metabase, what could be causing this?
The smtp setup in Metabase can cause a 550 5.7.60 SMTP error.
Can Metabase be used to display comments on Postgres tables?
Yes, Metabase can be used to display comments on Postgres tables.
Is it possible to edit data in Snowflake or Athena through Metabase?
No, Metabase does not allow editing of data in Snowflake and Athena.
What kind of license does Metabase use?
Metabase uses the APGL license.
Use Cases for Metabase
-
Bringing company-wide transparency to customer care
-
Helping teams get insights from data
-
Transforming data analysis
-
Embedding analytics in SaaS platforms
-
Creating efficient business reporting systems
Advantages of Google Looker for Business Intelligence
Enterprise Business Intelligence Tool
Google Looker Studio Pro serves as an enterprise-grade business intelligence platform, providing robust capabilities for data exploration and visualization.
Data Exploration and Visualization
The platform enables users to answer complex business questions through advanced data exploration and build insightful visualizations.
Enterprise Capabilities
Designed for medium and large enterprises, Looker Studio Pro offers extensive features to manage and govern large datasets and user bases.
Content Management and Team Collaboration
Effective team content management tools and support for collaboration make it suitable for teams to work together on data analytics.
Enterprise Support and Environment
Users benefit from access to enterprise-level support and a platform optimized for large-scale enterprise environments.
Dashboard Sharing
The tool excels in creating and sharing dashboards, promoting data-driven decision-making across the organization.
Disadvantages of Using Google Looker
Learning Curve and Usability
Google Looker presents a steep learning curve that can be challenging for users. The platform is not very intuitive, which can hinder efficiency and productivity during the initial adoption phase. The complexity of Looker's sharing mechanisms further complicates user experience.
Performance Issues
Users frequently report that the platform's performance is slow, especially when handling many graphs on a single page. This lag can significantly impact the timely retrieval and analysis of business intelligence data.
Onboarding and Training
Onboarding new users onto Looker can be an expensive endeavor. Training materials and comprehensive documentation are not readily accessible, which can prolong the onboarding process and delay full deployment.
Data Management and Migration
Migrating data, particularly from AWS to BigQuery, has been identified as a painful process for businesses. This can create bottlenecks and increase the time required to set up and utilize Looker for data analytics.
Connectivity and Access
The platform lacks seamless connectivity options, potentially limiting integration with other systems. Furthermore, the security protocols can be restrictive, as access is often heavily tied down by security teams, affecting flexibility and accessibility.
Website Performance
The Looker website itself has been described as slow, which can be detrimental to user experience and can negatively impact the efficiency of reporting and data analysis tasks.
Frequently Asked Questions About Google Looker
When is Looker Support available for English language users?
Looker Support is available 24/7 in English.
How can I ensure my Looker instance receives support?
Ensure your Looker instance is running an officially supported Looker version. If you have a customer-hosted instance, update to a supported version if necessary. For Looker (original) instances, fill in the Google Cloud Project number on the Admin General Settings page.
What are the support hours for Looker in Japanese?
Support in Japanese is available from 9:00 AM JST – 5:00 PM JST, Monday – Friday, and from 5:00 PM JST – 9:00 AM JST, Monday – Saturday, including weekends and holidays.
Who is eligible for Looker Support?
Looker Support is available to users with the Tech Support EditorIAM role and to administrators and developers on instances using Legacy Support.
What should I do when submitting a support request?
You may be prompted to choose from a product area when submitting a support request.
Use Cases for Google Looker
-
Reducing client report time
-
Modernizing business intelligence
-
Embedding analytics in quote-to-revenue platforms
Why Sourcetable is a Superior Alternative for Business Intelligence
-
Simplified Data Management
Sourcetable streamlines the business intelligence process by integrating data from multiple services into a spreadsheet-like interface. This reduces the complexity of managing various data sources, a common challenge with tools like Metabase and Google Looker.
-
User-Friendly Interface
The spreadsheet-like interface of Sourcetable is familiar to most users, making it easier to adopt and use without the learning curve associated with Metabase's visual query builders or Looker's LookML.
-
Enhanced Reporting Capabilities
With Sourcetable, users can generate reports swiftly, leveraging the intuitive layout and data manipulation features inherent to spreadsheets. This contrasts with the more rigid reporting frameworks of Metabase and Looker.
-
Integrated Data Analytics
Sourcetable offers a cohesive analytics experience by syncing data across all connected services, thereby providing a consolidated view that can be more cumbersome to achieve with Metabase or Looker.
-
Accessibility and Collaboration
The accessibility of Sourcetable's spreadsheet interface encourages collaboration across teams, unlike the potentially restrictive access controls in Metabase's Pro plan or Looker's user groups.
-
Cost-Effectiveness
Sourcetable's straightforward approach can lead to reduced costs by minimizing the need for specialized training or additional tools for data analytics, which may be necessary with more complex BI tools like Metabase and Looker.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Comparing Metabase and Google Looker
Business Intelligence and Analytics
Both Metabase and Google Looker serve as business intelligence tools, aiding companies in data analytics to derive insights and make informed decisions.
User-Friendly Interfaces
Metabase and Google Looker are designed with user-friendly interfaces, facilitating non-technical users to perform data exploration and analysis with ease.
Self-Service Analytics
They both enable self-service analytics, allowing users within an organization to create dashboards and reports without extensive technical skills.
Data Source Connectivity
Metabase and Google Looker can connect to a variety of data sources, providing flexibility in accessing and visualizing data from multiple databases and data warehouses.
Deployment Options
Each offers different deployment options to suit various business needs, including cloud-based solutions and open-source versions.
Embeddable Dashboards
Both tools provide functionalities to embed analytic content such as charts and dashboards into other applications, enhancing integrated business intelligence capabilities.
Security and Compliance
Metabase and Google Looker come with enterprise-grade security features and comply with major regulations, ensuring data protection and privacy for users.
Customization and Extensibility
They offer diverse customization options and extensibility, catering to the specific analytic requirements of different business environments.
Metabase vs. Google Looker
Metabase is an analytics and business intelligence tool with a focus on self-service and ease of use. It offers a user-friendly interface that enables non-technical users to explore data and create dashboards. Metabase is available in a free open-source tier, as well as paid Pro and Enterprise plans. It connects to over 20 data sources and supports embedding of charts and dashboards.
Metabase is an analytics and business intelligence tool with a focus on self-service and ease of use. It offers a user-friendly interface that enables non-technical users to explore data and create dashboards. Metabase is available in a free open-source tier, as well as paid Pro and Enterprise plans. It connects to over 20 data sources and supports embedding of charts and dashboards.
Google Looker, on the other hand, is a more enterprise-focused business intelligence tool that provides data exploration capabilities with an emphasis on real-time data access. Looker typically requires a stronger technical background to utilize its modeling language, LookML, for defining data relationships and transformations.
Deployment and Cost
User Accessibility
Integration and Embedding
Compliance and Security
Comparative Analysis: Metabase, Google Looker, and Sourcetable
Deployment and Data Sources
Metabase offers deployment through Metabase Cloud or as open-source software, with rapid deployment in three minutes and connection to over 20 data sources without the need for data extracts. Google Looker does not specify deployment times or the exact number of data sources it can connect to. Sourcetable's deployment and data source capabilities have not been provided for comparison.
User Experience and Accessibility
Metabase is recognized for its friendly UX and accessibility to all users. Google Looker also provides a user-friendly experience with self-service capabilities. The user experience and accessibility of Sourcetable remain unspecified.
Analytics and Business Intelligence
Both Metabase and Google Looker support self-service analytics, with Metabase allowing companies to explore data on their own and Looker offering self-service BI. Looker extends its capabilities to governed BI and the ability to build data-powered applications, including embedded analytics and data modeling. Metabase's analytics capabilities are broadly described without specific mention of data-powered application development. Sourcetable's analytics and BI features are not detailed here.
Pricing and Plans
Metabase provides a free open-source tier and a pay-as-you-go Pro plan targeting enterprise users with advanced features such as permissions, caching, audit, and governance controls. Google Looker does not disclose specific pricing plans or tiers, focusing on the range of BI applications it supports. Sourcetable's pricing structure is not mentioned for this comparison.
Advanced Features and Enterprise Use
Conclusion
Metabase and Google Looker both offer robust platforms for analytics and business intelligence, with distinct strengths in deployment speed, user experience, and enterprise features. Metabase's approachable UX and quick deployment contrast with Looker's comprehensive BI tools and application development capabilities. Sourcetable's features and positioning relative to Metabase and Looker are incomplete in this context, necessitating further information for a comprehensive comparison.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Frequently Asked Questions About Sourcetable
What is Sourcetable and who typically uses it?
Sourcetable is a spreadsheet application that replaces traditional workflows done in Excel, Google Sheets, and Business Intelligence tools. It is typically used by growth teams and business operations people.
How does Sourcetable integrate with other applications?
Sourcetable syncs data from over 100 applications and most databases. Data integrations update every 15 minutes on the regular plan and every 5 minutes on the pro plan.
Do I need to know how to code to use Sourcetable?
No, Sourcetable does not require any coding to use.
How much does Sourcetable cost?
Sourcetable costs $50 per month on the starter plan and $250 per month on the pro plan. Additional seats cost $20 per month per user.
Is there a trial period for Sourcetable?
Yes, all plans come with a 14-day free trial period.
Metabase Pricing Plans
-
Starter Plan
The Metabase Starter plan is priced at $85 per month, accommodating up to 5 users. Additional users can be added at $5 per month each. Annually, the Starter plan is $918, with a per-user cost of $54.
-
Pro Plan
Metabase's Pro plan is available for $500 per month and includes 10 users. Extra users are charged at $10 per month. The annual rate for this plan is $5400, with an individual user cost of $108 per year.
-
Enterprise Plan
The Enterprise plan has custom pricing, starting at a minimum of $15,000 per year per user. This plan's pricing is tailored per user.
-
Open Source Plan
Metabase also offers an Open Source plan that is free to use.
-
Annual Billing Discount
A 10% discount is offered for all plans when billed annually.
Google Looker Pricing Structure
-
Overview of Pricing Components
Looker pricing incorporates two fundamental elements: platform pricing and user pricing. Platform pricing is the cost associated with running a Looker instance, covering aspects such as platform administration, integrations, and semantic modeling. User pricing relates to the individual user licenses required to access the Looker platform.
-
Platform Pricing
Platform pricing is mandatory for operating a Looker instance. This fee encompasses the necessary tools and services for platform administration, the ability to perform integrations, and leveraging semantic modeling capabilities.
-
User Pricing
User pricing is determined by the type of user license and the permissions granted within the Looker platform. Different user roles, such as Developer User, Standard User, and Viewer User, are subject to varying licensing costs.
-
Billing and Account Management
Each Looker instance is connected to a billing account, which is charged for any new instances created or additional users added. The billing is directly associated with the selected Looker platform edition and the user licenses.
-
Editions and Subscription Terms
Looker offers three platform editions: Standard, Enterprise, and Embed. The costs for these editions are influenced by user types and their permissions. Subscriptions for these editions can be obtained in annual terms, with options of one, two, or three years.
User Reviews of Metabase
-
Overall Satisfaction
Metabase has an overall rating of 4.5 out of 5, indicating high user satisfaction. Reviewers frequently award Metabase with a perfect 5.0 rating in areas such as ease of use, customer service, features, and value for money.
-
Usability and Accessibility
Users commend Metabase for its ease of use, especially for those with minimal technical knowledge. Its user interface is praised for being great and facilitating self-service analytics. The tool's ability to send alerts and its versatility beyond dashboards are also highlighted.
-
Performance and Limitations
- Metabase can experience significant delays and latency when handling more data.
- Under heavier loads, Metabase has been reported to crash and become buggy, affecting data rendering speed.
- Some users have encountered issues with loading or downloading reports.
-
Setup and Integration
Metabase is recognized for its straightforward setup and deployment. It integrates well with SQL and Google Analytics, and it supports self-hosted options for free. However, complex configurations may be required for running in open source mode.
-
Features and Customization
Reviewers appreciate Metabase's capabilities in building dashboards, analyzing data, and tracking KPIs. Despite not being the most advanced analytics tool and lacking features such as joins between different databases, it remains a market leader in analytics.
-
Open Source Contributions
While Metabase is an open source tool, contributing to its codebase may pose challenges due to it being written in CoffeeScript.
User Reviews of Google Looker
-
General Sentiments
Google Looker is recognized as a business intelligence (BI) and analytics platform. It has received criticism for its performance with some users labeling it as the worst reporting tool available.
-
Common Complaints
- Reports of slow performance.
- Instances of bugs within the software.
- User experience described as unintuitive.
-
Comparisons with Other Products
Users have expressed a preference for alternative BI tools. Free and paid products like Data Studio and Tableau are often cited as superior to Looker.
Conclusion
In summary, Metabase and Google Looker offer distinct approaches to business intelligence. Metabase provides user-friendly analytics without a steep learning curve, while Google Looker features robust data modeling capabilities and advanced analytics.
For those seeking a more streamlined solution, Sourcetable offers real-time synchronization of data across services within a spreadsheet interface, simplifying the business intelligence process.
Try Sourcetable
Simplify your BI tooling with a spreadsheet that syncs with all your data.
Learn More
Simplify Your BI Tooling
Sourcetable is the AI spreadsheet that lets you analyze your data in one place. Get unlimited access free for 14 days.